Archive

Archive for the ‘Tweet Summary’ Category

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (Oct 2017)

October 13, 2017 Leave a comment

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guyPV or sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments or Enduring Intellectual Properties. Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here or get it a little cheaper on our site here.

  • Friday the 13th and a heavy data day. What could go wrong?
  • 10y breakevens at local highs of 1.90% – but that’s the biggest spread over core CPI in several years.
  • …yet we still have 10y TIPS 50bps to fair at this level of interest rates.
  • Economist expectations are for 0.21% on core and 1.78% y/y. Interesting given how low it has been recently.
  • I don’t usually look at headline but the y/y number is forecast to jump to 2.3% from 1.9%. That will get some attention.
  • I think the market forecasts are about right for core, but there’s a wide range of upside risks. Autos are due to catch up, e.g.
  • But that’s why the forecasts make sense. 0.15% for trend plus 0.05% for expected value of risks.
  • …in turn, that means the point forecasts are not the most likely prints. They’re in between the most likely prints.
  • Core +0.13%, 1.69% y/y.
  • Breakdown will be interesting. Housing broad category went to 2.79% y/y from 2.91%. Medical Care fell to 1.56% from 1.81%.
  • Used cars/trucks went to -3.7% vs -3.8% y/y, so that rebound is still ahead of us. Surveys of car prices are up a lot, just not in BLS yet.
  • pulling in the breakdown now…core services 2.6% from 2.5%, but core goods deflation deepens to -1.0% from -0.9%.
  • Core goods deflation, however, ought soon to be rising again after the lagged effect of the dollar’s decline passes in.
  • In Housing, Primary Rents plunged to 3.78% from 3.88%. That’s huge. OER dropped to 3.18% from 3.27%. Also huge. There’s your story.
  • Core ex-housing rose to 0.58% vs 0.52% y/y, so there’s more going on here but the housing. Wow.
  • A few months ago we had y/y OER fall by more, but that was when OER was overextended.
  • Here is primary rents y/y. I guess this isn’t DRAMATIC – just quite contrary to my own expectations for a continuation of the rebound.

  • In Medical Care, Medicinal Drugs fell to 1.01% from 2.51%. Wow! But Professional Services and Hospital Services accelerated slightly.
  • Here’s CPI for pharma. Think we’ve discussed this before – likely compositional in nature, more generics thanks to worse insurance.

  • Professional services (doctors) bounced;not significant. Also somewhat compositional as old doctors quit rather than take ins. headaches.

  • College Tuition 2.08% vs 1.89%. Have I mentioned the new S&P Target Tuition Inflation Index recently? 🙂
  • Just b/c …who can get enough of wireless telecom services? Bounced, mostly base effect of course. Bottom line was that dip was a 1-off.

  • New cars also still deflating, BTW. -1.0% vs -0.68%. Obviously this will change with Houston buying loads of new cars.
  • Speaking of Houston: core CPI in Houston y/y ended June: 1.31%. For y/y ended Aug: 1.90%. But that’s actually before Harvey.
  • In Miami, 2.01% vs. 2.26% (June vs August). Have to wait a bit to get October numbers – they’ll come out in Dec.
  • Bottom line on the storms is that we haven’t seen the impact yet on CPI. Still to come.
  • My early estimate of Median CPI is 0.20%, bringing y/y up to 2.17% from 2.15%.
  • Housing and Medical Care still keeping pressure on core.

  • Interestingly, these other categories, including Food, and Energy too, all saw acceleration this month (except for other).

  • distribution of changes getting more spread out…

  • Percentage of basket over 3% hasn’t changed much, ergo median didn’t change much.

  • Does this change the Fed’s calculus? I don’t think so, especially with wages accelerating. Still waiting for one-offs to unwind.
  • The doves will argue that the unwind of a one-off is itself a one-off and we should therefore look thru and see 0.12-0.14 as the trend.
  • They’re unlikely to carry the day in Dec, even if the data don’t bounce higher. But if core stays weak the mkt will unwind the 3 in 2018.
  • 10y breakevens -3bps since the number. Market had seemed a little long but this is still too low for breakevens.
  • Four pieces. Piece 1: Food & Energy

  • Piece 2: core goods. Won’t go down forever with the dollar well off its highs.

  • Core services less ROS. A bounce. Sustainable? We’ll have to see.

  • Piece 4, Rent of Shelter. Seemingly ignoring continued rise in home prices. Back to model but weaker than I expected.

  • Last chart. here is the argument: do we cheer the weak consumer inflation or worry about higher wages?

  • Yes, wages follow inflation rather than lead…but the Fed doesn’t believe that.

Thanks to everyone who followed my new “premium” (but cheap) channel. I wrote on Wednesday about the reason for changing my Tweet storm; in a nutshell, it’s because research is starting to be priced a la carte at the major dealers and hopefully this means that quality but off-Street analysis might finally be competing on an even footing rather than competing with “free.” If you think there’s value in what I do, I’d appreciate a follow. If not…well, if the market tells me that what I’m producing isn’t worth anything, then I’ll stop producing it of course!

But in the meantime, here is the story of CPI this month. A continuing regression of rents and OER to model levels held core down to recent-trend levels. But there are many one-off and temporary effects that are due to be reversed, and relationships that suggest certain components are due to catch up to underlying realities. For example, here is the picture of Used Cars and Trucks CPI, compared to the Manheim Used Vehicle Value Index 4 months prior.

According to the relationship between these series over the last decade, CPI for Used Cars and Trucks should be growing about 5% faster than it is presently, and rise another 3-4% in the next few months. New and Used Motor Vehicles inflation is about 8% of core CPI, so this effect alone could add 0.7% to core CPI! Or, put another way, right now core CPI is about 0.4% lower than it would be if the CPI was measuring the actual price of vehicles the same way that Manheim does it. That’s a big number when the entire core CPI is only 1.7%.

The continued, and actually extended weakness in core goods is also due to reverse. I don’t mean that core goods inflation will go from -1% to +3% but only to 0.5%. But that 150bp acceleration, in one-quarter of the core CPI, would also raise core CPI by 40bps or so. To be sure, there is some double-counting since a third of core commodities is new and used vehicles, but that merely reinforces the message.

So, too, are the effects in medical. Volatility in those series should persist, which means that since they are at a low ebb there’s a better bet that the next volatile swing is to higher prices.

All of which is to say that the hawks on the Federal Reserve Board actually have it right, in a sense. Prices are headed higher, and inflation is accelerating. It would be a truly shocking development if core inflation one year from now was unchanged from the current level. Indeed, I think there is a better chance that core inflation is above 2.7% than below 1.7%. On another level, the hawks aren’t quite right though. By hiking rates before draining excess reserves, the Fed risks kicking off the vicious cycle I have mentioned before: higher rates cause higher money velocity, which causes higher inflation, which causes higher rates etc. Without control of reserves at the margin, the Fed cannot control money supply growth and so the normal offset to rising monetary velocity in a tightening cycle, slowing money growth, comes down to chance. Either way, the Fed is very likely to tighten in December, but beyond that it probably matters more who ends up in the Chairman’s seat than anything economic data.

Advertisements

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (Sep 2017)

September 14, 2017 Leave a comment

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy or sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments or Enduring Intellectual Properties. Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here or get it a little cheaper on our site here.

  • 15 minutes to go to CPI. Consensus on core is for 0.17% or so. But due to tough year-ago comparison, y/y should drop to 1.6%
  • Hurricane effects may boost headline a bit, though most of that will be later. Shouldn’t see core effects yet.
  • Core effects may potentially be seen (eventually) in shelter and vehicles; both were destroyed in large amounts in Harvey/Irma
  • well well well. Core +0.249%, ALMOST 0.3% rounded. y/y to 1.69%
  • Turnabout is fair play. Highest core CPI in 8 months, and haven’t seen hurricane effect yet.

  • Note the easy comparisons from year ago for the next couple of months, too. Might just have seen the lows in core.
  • housing up, medical care down again. Drilling down now…
  • core services was up to 2.5% from 2.4%…core goods down to -0.9% from -0.6%! With dollar weakening that’s going to change.
  • Housing 2.91% from 2.83% y/y. Primary rents 3.88% from 3.81%; OER 3.27% vs 3.21%.
  • Lodging Away from Home +0.23% vs -2.36% y/y. That was one of those one-offs. Poof.
  • Motor vehicles -1.57% vs -1.72%. No hurricane effect yet but as I said on Bloomberg today…that’s likely to be a big + going forward
  • 81% vs 2.58% last month on Medical Care as a whole. Medicinal Drugs: 2.51% v 3.84%. Hospitals 4.09% v 5.31%. Insurance 0.17% v 1.24%
  • Professional services (medical) unch at just +0.2% y/y.
  • Figure out whether this medical care pricing collapse is temporary or real and you have the big story.
  • medicinal drugs:

  • Housing and medical care. I think the Medical Care move is mostly a composition change, catching more self-pay from insurance-pay.

  • Does this change anything for the Fed? Not with the hurricanes. Expect movement to reduce balance sheet, while holding rates down.
  • Enough for today. Will put up my summary article later. If you want the chartbook go to https://store.enduringip.com
  • [later:] Median CPI was 0.247%, y/y at 2.15% up from 2.13%, basically stable since June between 2.13% and 2.18%.

This was a shorter string of tweets than I usually produce. Part of the reason for that was that I was in a car careening down the highway returning from my appearance on Bloomberg TV to talk about the Phillips curve and auto inflation, and partly it was because this one was pretty easy.

Lodging Away from Home jumped. But it had previously plunged inexplicably, so this is just a reversal. I didn’t tweet about that one, but it is symptomatic – there are a number of one-offs, and some of them are going to reverse.

Rents rose a bit, but again that is partly just a retracement of the recent slide. As I pointed out last month, that slide merely put rents back on the model where they had been running ahead of the model, so this isn’t terribly surprising.

The really surprising part was and is the Medical Care part. All subcomponents of that index are now decelerating, although pharmaceuticals are doing so in a slightly less-dramatic fashion than medical professional services. This is very outside of anyone’s forecast ranges. It is possible this is just payback for the rises the previous year, but if that’s the case then it’s not going to continue. Is it possible that we suddenly have reined in the price of medical care by making it hard to acquire? I suppose that’s possible, but I would think the better bet is that the composition of services is changing as people are paying for more out of pocket – so we buy the band-aid rather than the tourniquet, and that looks like lower prices. It is, however, really hard to tell at this point and that’s the main remaining conundrum.

I said up top that the important hurricane effects, notably in Motor Vehicles but also in Shelter, have not been felt yet. (Read more about these upcoming effects in my column “Some Effects on Inflation from Harvey and Irma”). Moreover, the next few months will see core CPI comparisons of 0.12%, 0.15%, and 0.18% from last year. Accordingly, I think core which is currently at 1.69% will be at 1.77% next month, 1.82% the following month, and 1.84% the month after that. Importantly, none of that is enough to scare the Fed into hiking again, and with the hurricane damage I think they’ll eschew further rate hikes for a while. However, they will probably start reducing the balance sheet, and if they can manage to sustain that – reverse QE, but holding policy rates down – then they will have lucked into the “right” policy that could keep inflation’s peak in the 3%-4% range rather than the 5%+ trajectory that many of their other paths have. I am skeptical they will stay the course, because reverse QE will have bad effects on asset prices. But it’s a start.

Categories: CPI, Tweet Summary

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (August 2017)

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy or sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments. Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

  • about 15 mins to CPI. Consensus on core is 0.15% or 0.16% m/m, which would see y/y rise to ~1.74% vs 1.71%.
  • Few see upside risks to that forecast. Indeed, most pundits are braced for a lower print. 0.15% on core would have beaten last 4 mo.
  • Last 4 core CPI: -0.12%, 0.07%, 0.06%, 0.12%. But the 4 before that were 0.18%, 0.22%, 0.31%, and 0.21% so it’s a fair bet.
  • Though the NKor situation dominates market concerns, today’s CPI garnering more than normal interest. Potential for some volatility.
  • We’ve heard dovish Fed govs floating idea of pausing rate hikes (though continuing balance sheet reduction). That’s what doves do, but…
  • …but another weak CPI will be seen as “sealing the deal” for removing rate hikes from the calendar.
  • STRONG core CPI print is a much bigger surprise to most. Might be less mkt risk though – want to sell Tsys with NKor situation hot?
  • Core CPI 0.11%, y/y: 1.70%. Actually slightly down v 1.71% last mo. Think we can take rate hikes off table but will look @ breakdn.
  • Core goods steady at -0.6%, no dollar effect pushing it higher yet. Core services 2.4%, lowest in 2yrs.
  • Just quick glance I see new cars -1.1% y/y down from -0.3%. If this is autos I’d not be as worried.
  • Core ex-Shelter rose slightly, actually, to 0.63% from 0.60% y/y. But that’s obviously not alarming.
  • Dropping the full data set at the moment. Please hold.
  • In Housing, Primary Rents decelerated to 3.81% from 3.86%. OER slipped to 3.21% vs 3.23%. Small moved but big categories.
  • Lodging Away from Home -2.36% vs -0.07%. Big move, small category. But that category often has big moves.
  • Apparel went to -0.44% vs -0.67%. Again, not really seeing the dollar effect – apparel is one of the first places it would show up.
  • New cars -0.63% vs 0.01%, weight of 3.68% of CPI. Not only the lowest in 8 years but…recession leader? See chart.

  • Used cars -4.08% vs -4.30%, so the effect is in new.
  • That new cars decel is worth 3bps on core, so if was still at 0.01% we’d have had core right at expectations even w/ shelter slowdn.
  • Medical Care 2.58% vs 2.66% y/y. Pharma rose (3.84% vs 3.31%) but Prof Svcs dropped to 0.21% vs 0.58%
  • Medical – Professional Services starting to look like Telecommunications. What’s the one-off here?

  • Again with rents…decelerating but right about back on schedule.

  • For those playing at home: wireless telephone services -13.25% vs -13.19%. After the huge drop a few months ago, not much add’l.
  • Incidentally, Land Line Phone Services is 0.73% weight in CPI while Wireless is 1.74%. Gone is the ubiquitous creamcicle on the wall.
  • A little hard to guess at Median b/c median category looks like Midwest Urban OER, which gets a 2nd seasonal adj, but my est is 0.18%.
  • Here’s the inflation story over the last year, in two important chunks.

  • US #Inflation mkt pricing: 2017 1.3%;2018 1.8%;then 2.1%, 2.1%, 2.1%, 2.2%, 2.1%, 2.1%, 2.3%, 2.4%, & 2027:2.4%.
  • Here’s a little teaser from our quarterly. These are not forecasts, but entirely derived from mkt data.

  • Inflation in four pieces: Food & Energy

  • Piece 2: Core Goods, nothing to see here.

  • Core Services Less RoS – this is the core CPI story.

  • …though don’t forget piece 4. As noted earlier, this is just going back to model but some will forecast collapse.

  • This might be the bigger story – declining core CPI is all about the weight in the left tail, which is why median is still at 2.2%.

  • Despite core CPI slowdown, 44% of components are still inflating faster than 3%.

  • …this makes it more likely the recent CPI slowdown reverses, b/c it’s being caused by left-tail outcomes that probly mean-revert.

Coming into today the market thought the probability of a December rate hike was only 38%, which seemed very low to me. But there is nothing here that suggests the doves are going to lose the fight to slow down the already-timid pace of rate hikes. It isn’t surprising to see markets rally on this data.

However, it is also easy to get carried away with the story that inflation is decelerating. Those left-tail categories are what is driving core inflation lower (and it’s the reason I focus on median CPI, because it ignores the outliers). Shelter has come off the boil a bit, and if that rolled over I would be more concerned about seeing much lower CPI. But there is no sign of that happening, and it seems unlikely to given that home prices themselves continue to rise at a better-than-5% clip (see chart, source Bloomberg).

So, if shelter isn’t going to continue to decelerate much more, then the risk going forward is mean-reversion of those left-tail categories. I don’t think Physician Services are going to go into deflation. (To be sure, some of that is probably a measurement issue as the mode of hiring and paying for doctors is changing, and it is hard to predict mean reversion from measurement issues). Thus, if the market starts to price a near-zero chance of higher rates come December, I’d be interested in buying that option on the chance that one or two of these next four CPI prints (the December CPI report is out the day of the December FOMC meeting) is tilted the other way.

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (July 2017)

July 14, 2017 2 comments

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy or sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments. Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

  • quick CPI review: last 3 months have been -0.12%, +0.07%, and +0.06% on core CPI – that is, basically flat.
  • three months before that were 0.22%, 0.31%, and 0.21%. Basically a 3% annualized rate. Which of these is “right”?
  • Market has become convinced something around the current 1.75% average is “right.” But we’ve had big misses both sides.
  • Consensus for today is for 0.2% on core, 1.7% y/y, but that’s a very narrow range. Basically 0.15% m/m gets both of those.
  • If we get 0.16%, then y/y should round up to 1.8% y/y. If we get 0.14%, then m/m rounds down to 0.1%.
  • Of course, recent months have shown us something wildly different is possible!
  • core CPI 0.119%, again below consensus…y/y drops to 1.71%.
  • This is closer to the summer lull we’ve seen recently. But still low. Here are the last 12 months of core CPI.

  • That chart is weird, looks like there was a dramatic effect in March that’s wearing off. But it’s actually been a series of one-offs.
  • Core services at 2.5% y/y, down from 2.6% (and down from 3.1% as recently as Feb). Core goods -0.6%, up from -0.8%.
  • Core CPI ex-shelter was basically unchanged at 0.6% y/y, matching 13-year lows.

  • Owners Equiv Rent was +3.23% y/y, Primary Rents 3.86% vs 3.85%. So the low print isn’t main part of housing.
  • But housing overall – the major subgroup – decelerated to 3.02% from 3.12%. So that deceleration is elsewhere.
  • Medical Care CPI was unchanged at 2.66% y/y.
  • Pharma inflation 3.31% from 3.34%. Professional Services 0.58% from 1.0%. But hospital services 5.65% from 4.95%.
  • This chart is physician’s services. I’m really curious about this.

  • An optimist could say ‘this is b/c high deductibles under Ocare force consumers to negotiate aggressively with doctors.”
  • Pessimist: “even if that’s true, it means fewer doctors tomorrow, ergo higher prices.” & where is this effect in hospital prices?
  • I don’t see anything very quirky in these numbers unlike past months. OER still converging with our model.

  • If there’s “nothing unusual,” it suggests underlying core rate is something near 1.5%. But inflation always on the way to somewhere.
  • Four-pieces breakdown: Food & Energy

  • Four-pieces breakdown: Core Goods. Still bumping along, but this will turn higher as USD weakens.

  • Four-pieces breakdown: Core Svcs less Rent of Shelter. This continues to be The Story.

  • Four-pieces breakdown: Rent of Shelter – as I said, ebbing but just because it was ahead of itself. Housing isn’t about to deflate.

  • As @pearkes points out, core services ex-housing largely a medical story, and that’s likely temporary. Chart for CPI medical care:

  • I find it ironic: if Ocare IS helping to contain health care, it’s b/c consumers negotiate harder when they don’t really have health care.
  • …which would seem to run counter to the professed reason for the ACA, which was to increase coverage. Is it working b/c it’s not working?
  • Enough CPI for today. Don’t forget to buy my book!
  • Also, good friend just published a thriller: http://amzn.to/2um7vIi He’s a very engaging author if you like fiction.

It was just a few months ago that we worried about whether core inflation was about to accelerate past 3%. Then, we had a few months where some people (not me!) worried that we were suddenly plunging into deflation and core inflation was around 0%. The reality seems to be somewhere in the middle. The recent ultra-low prints are clearly the results of one-offs, but it also seems as if the ongoing upward pressures – for example, in housing – have come off the boil as well. Back when rents were surging, I was worried that our model was perhaps not capturing some other dynamic and that rents would run away to the upside; in the event, it was probably just noise.

So what is the true underlying dynamic? We have to remember that economic statistics are just experiments – samples of an unknowable distribution. And, since economic data is very noisy, it usually takes a lot of data to be able to say for sure that something has changed. Economists and other prognosticators are usually not so patient. We got a weak number, and we want to say right now that something fundamental has changed. It doesn’t work that way.

Inflation data are usually fairly stable (once you strip out food and energy), so a couple of surprising figures is often enough to signal a changing dynamic. But one curious aspect of the last year’s worth of core inflation data is that it has been very volatile – in fact close to being the most volatile in the last twenty years:

There are a couple of implications to that observation, but the key one here is that it means it’s harder to reject any particular null hypothesis when the data are all over the place.

So here’s the summary: the main contributor to lower core inflation that is difficult to shrug off completely is the abrupt plunge in medical care inflation. This also happens to be the category that is most difficult to measure, since most consumers do not directly pay for much of their health care…or, anyway, they didn’t until Obamacare led to dramatic increases in deductibles. But that change in who pays for health care makes it very difficult to disentangle what the price of health care is actually doing, as opposed to the quantity of health care consumed. Very, very difficult.

My suspicion, based on direct observation and conversations with professionals in hospital and practice management, is that there are indeed pressures to contain healthcare costs, part of which are being caused by the fact consumers are having to negotiate directly with doctors for care and part of which are the result of other institutional pressures, such as the effect of Medicare/Obamacare legislation on formulary negotiations. Does that mean Obamacare is “succeeding?” If the sole purpose of the ACA was to lower health care costs by reducing the consumption of health care – maybe it is, at least in the short run. Certainly, there is a lot of energy on the entrepreneurial side dedicated to finding ways to cut costs, and lots of inefficiencies that can be wrung out…and, if “angry consumers” is the impetus for organizations finally wringing out these inefficiencies, I suppose that’s not a bad thing.

As I said earlier, I think it’s too early and there’s too much noise to say that something fundamental has changed. Heck, a year ago I thought medical inflation was about to run away on the upside (and I wasn’t alone, as the Republican sweep of Congress attests). I am not about to be fooled in the opposite direction as easily. What I will say is that I have trouble believing that inflation in the cost of physicians’ services is going to go negative, or stay near zero for a long time. I could be wrong, but I suspect that part of the pendulum will start to swing back over the next six months.

Categories: ACA, CPI, Tweet Summary

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (June 2017)

June 14, 2017 3 comments

Special request: if you get value from these pieces, please take a moment to respond to my survey/market research – it will take about three minutes – and forward to everyone you know! I am looking for 1,000 responses. Please help, and remember that these posts are all free to you!

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy or sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments. Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

  • CPI day! People looking past CPI at 8:30 but…not me!
  • Last 2 CPI prints were very low. The first was a 1-off wireless telecom debacle, read about that effect here.
  • Last month’s CPI weakness was in core services – in medical care & rent of shelter. Harder to ignore but unlikely to be in freefall.
  • Consensus core CPI is for another weak print, only 0.16% or so. Economists believe disinflation is upon us. I think that’s premature.
  • Last May’s core CPI was 0.21%, so that’s the hurdle to get acceleration in y/y figures.
  • WOW! At this rate I will have to change my Twitter handle. Each month is more shocking. m/m core 0.1%, not sure on the rounding yet.
  • 06% m/m on core CPI, so again incredibly weak. y/y at 1.74%, producing the scary optic of a drop from 1.9% to 1.7% on the rounded core
  • This is an amazing chart.

  • waiting for the data dump, but housing, medical care, apparel subcomponents all decelerated.
  • So the upshot is…core prices overall are unchanged from February. That’s right, 0% core inflation over 3 months.
  • Yes, it was telecom that made 0% possible and that won’t be repeated. But still striking. Here is the index itself.

  • So Dec, Jan, Feb core inflation is rising at a 3% annualized pace. next 3 months, zero. That’s not supposed to happen to core.
  • Breakdown now. In Housing, Primary rents remain solid at 3.85% y/y, unch. But Owners’ Equiv plunged (for it) to 3.25% from 3.39%.
  • Picture of OER: this is a dramatic shift in this index, and frankly hard to explain given home price increases.

  • Medical Care decelerated to 2.66% from 2.95%. But w/in MC, drugs rose to 3.34% vs 2.62%. Professional svcs flopped to 1.00% from 1.58%
  • CPI/Med Care/Professional Services, y/y. Doctors suddenly don’t need to be paid.

  • Apparel had been at 0.45% y/y, fell to -0.94%.
  • The Fed funds rate is too low and almost certainly rises today. But with a sudden zig in CPI…it wouldn’t SHOCK me if they delayed.
  • Back to housing – we’ve believed OER was ahead of itself for awhile. Adjustment is just really sudden.

  • in the biggest-pieces breakdown, core goods is at -0.8% y/y while core services is down to 2.6%.
  • US$’s recent decline (2y change in trade-weighted $ is only +7%) means core goods are losing the downward pressure of last few yrs.
  • But the dollar’s effect is lagged significantly. We’re still seeing effect of prior strength.

  • Here are the four pieces of CPI, most volatile to least. Starting with Food & Energy (21% of CPI)

  • Core goods (33%)

  • Core services less Rent of Shelter. Yipe!

  • Got my percentages wrong. Food & Energy is 21%. Core goods is 19%, core services less ROS is 27%. Rent of Shelter is 33%.
  • Rent of Shelter. 27% of overall CPI. I still find it hard to believe this is going to collapse, but as I tweeted earlier it was ahead.

  • My early estimate of Median CPI is 0.18% m/m, 2.28% y/y down from 2.37%.
  • One thing to keep in mind is that in June and July we drop off 0.15% and 0.13% from y/y core. So core should bounce back some. (??)
  • I mean, we can’t average 0% core going forward, right?!? Otherwise @TheStalwart and @adsteel will never have me on again.
  • core ex-shelter down to 0.59% y/y. Lowest since JANUARY 2004!

  • Interestingly, the weight of categories inflating more than 3% remains high. The pullback is in the far left tail.

Well, it’s getting harder to put lipstick on this pig. The telecom-induced drop of a couple of months ago was clearly a one-off. But the slowdown in owners’-equivalent rents is merely putting it back in line with our model, and so it’s hard to believe that’s going to be reversed. And I’m really, really skeptical that there has been an abrupt collapse in the rate of increase of doctors’ wages.

Except, what if there is a shift happening from higher-priced doctors to lower-priced doctors? This sort of compositional shift happens all the time in the data and it’s devilishly hard to tease out – for example, in the Existing Home Sales report it is sometimes difficult to tell if a change in home prices is coming from a broad change in home prices, or because more high-priced or low-priced homes are being sold this month, skewing the average. So this kind of composition shift is possible, in which case each individual doctor could see his wages increasing while the average declines due to the composition effect. I have no idea if this is what is happening – I’m just making the point that if it is, then this effect could be more persistent and not the one-off that the telecom change was. However, I am skeptical.

I do not believe that we have seen a turn in the inflation cycle. With money growth persistently above 6%, it would take a further collapse in money velocity from already-record-low levels to get that to happen. Forget about the micro question, about whether movements in this index or that index look like they’re rolling over. The macro question is that it is hard to get disinflation if there’s too much money sloshing around, whether or not the economy is growing.

But that being said, the Fed doesn’t necessarily believe that. There is a tendency to believe one’s own fable, and the fable the FOMC tells itself is that raising interest rates causes growth to slow and inflation to decline. Although the effect is spurious, we are currently seeing somewhat slower growth (for example, in the recent slowing of payrolls) and we are seeing lower core inflation. It is a low hurdle for the Fed to believe that their policy moves are an important part of the cause of these effects. Of course, they’re not – the tiny changes the FOMC has made in the overnight rate, even if it had been propagated to significant changes in longer rates – which it hasn’t been – or resulted in slower month growth – it hasn’t, especially if you look globally – would not have had much effect at all. But that won’t stop them from thinking so. Ergo, the chance that the Fed skips today’s meeting, while small, are non-zero. And there is a much greater chance that the “dot plot” shifts lower as dovish members of the Fed (and that’s most of them) back away from the feeble pace of increases they’d been anticipating.

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (May 2017)

May 12, 2017 6 comments

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy or sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments. Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

This month, I am making sure to include my comments before the actual number, since my suspicions about the upside risk were exquisitely wrong. This is why you shouldn’t put a lot of weight on monthly figures, folks!

  • Step right up ladies and gents. The CPI circus is about to commence.
  • Last month’s circus crazier than usual, including an unprecedented (and inexplicable) 11+% drop in wireless telecom services. [Editor’s note: it was only 7%. I corrected this in a later tweet]
  • This caused more diversion in core and median CPI. Median (better measure) remains steady at 2.5%.

  • PPI y’day was broadly strong. I don’t pay much attention to PPI but it does create upside risk.
  • Also note that European inflation saw a drop and then big jump from the early Easter. Not sure we have an analog but…
  • Point is that consensus is for 0.17% or so. There’s a lot of upside risk to that number I think.
  • Over next few months, core will rise regardless as we drop off 0.18, 0.21, 0.15, and 0.13. Easy hurdles.
  • Wow! Core only 0.1% again! Even a low 0.1%…0.07%.
  • I cannot WAIT to get a look at the breakdown.
  • ..Medical Care ebbed from 3.5% y/y to 3.0% y/y, wanna look inside that one. Recreation and yes, communication also soft.
  • Core drops to 1.89% y/y. Lowest since late 2015. Of course, remember that median is a better measure – we’ll see that later.
  • [I retweeted this, look at Matthew’s yellow line here]

  • Wireless telecom services fell another 1.7%. Incidentally I earlier said 11% m/m was last mo…it was only 7% m/m, the 11% decline was y/y.
  • so wireless telecom services now down 12.9% y/y, 9.9% over the last 3 months. This really warrants explanation from BLS.
  • In Medical Care, Medical Drugs fell to 2.62% from 3.97% y/y. Professional svcs, which is twice the weight, fell to 1.58% from 2.50%.
  • Health insurance fell to 2.72% vs 3.34%. Lowest since 2015.
  • Medical decel seems implausible but remember is a rate of change measure. So rising from high level, but at slower rate, is lower CPI.
  • Let’s get to housing. Primary rents 3.84% vs 3.88%. OER fell to 3.39% from 3.49%, that’s a big drop for 25% of the index.
  • So overall, Housing rose from 3.1% to 3.2%, but that’s on the strength of a 1% rise in household energy y/y.
  • This is OER. The decline is actually welcome – it had been running well ahead of even our optimistic models.

  • Core goods steady at -0.6% y/y. So the deceleration in last two months is all from core services, from 3.1% to 2.9% to 2.7%.
  • I don’t see that slowdown in core services as sustainable unless housing rolls over…
  • …and I don’t see that happening while home prices keep rising at 6-7% as they have been.
  • Weakness in services outside of housing s/b taken with grain of salt though…a lot of that is wireless services!
  • But doing core-less-housing-and-wireless is cheating. We take out housing to look @ the wiggly stuff. Can’t also take out wiggly stuff.
  • OK, four-pieces CPI look. From most-wiggly to least. They tell the story. Food & Energy:

  • Core goods (about 19% of CPI)

  • Core services less rent-of-shelter (26% of CPI). <<BOOM>>

  • And Rent of Shelter (33.3%)

  • And within core services less ROS, a lot of that is wireless but medical care ebbing is also in there. That’s the story of this month.
  • On Median…I have 0.13% m/m, but the median category is an OER piece and the BLS seasonally adjusts those.
  • But my best guess on median is 0.13%, dropping y/y to 2.4%.
  • Maybe I’m wrong and inflation pressures are ebbing after all. You know who else is thinking that? Janet Yellen.
  • Forgot to tweet this chart earlier.

  • Also interesting. Core<median b/c of big weight in left tail. But also starting to be more weight in general left of mode.

  • Last routine chart: the weight of categories inflating faster than 3% is still almost half. It’s that left tail draggin’ stuff down.

It was easy to ignore last month’s negative core print. It was obviously tied to a ridiculous (and still not explained by the BLS) plummet in the price of wireless telecommunications services. A 7% fall, nationwide, in one month, that no one seems to have noticed, is something the BLS really needs to comment on (my best guess is that some data plans got uncapped, and the BLS assumed a large increase in the data taken at zero dollars and therefore a big drop in the price per gig. That’s effectively a hedonic adjustment, and a not unreasonable one if you really saw a dramatic increase in data being taken. Since I have yet to talk to anyone who saw anything that resembled this huge effect, I remain skeptical.) But in any event, it was easy to ignore March’s number released in April.

Now we have two months in a row, and while wireless telecom contributed this month as well, there was also softness in medical care and in owner’s equivalent rent. That’s harder to ignore. And while median CPI was steady after last month’s debacle, it should downtick today.

I don’t think inflation is done rising; I think this is just a pause. But as I said above, I am sure that the decline in core CPI and core PCE will not go unremarked at the next FOMC meeting – the one where they are supposed to hike rates again. I think we’ll learn a lot about the stomach the Fed has for continuing the rate normalization regime by whether they go through with the next hike.

Categories: CPI, Tweet Summary

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy or sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments. Plus…buy my book about money and inflation, published in March 2016. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

  • Pretty big market day! Importantly, CPI: remember last month was big upside surprise, and driven by unusual suspects – core goods.
  • There’s a decent base effect hurdle today, as last Feb was 0.25% on core CPI. Consensus today is for a very weak 0.2% (almost 0.1%).
  • The consensus forecast clearly says that most economists see last month’s shocking 0.31% on core as one-offs.
  • Consensus expectation is for core to slip back to 2.2% from 2.3%. But then, last month they thought we’d fall to 2.1%.
  • Hurdles get easier next month: March ’16 saw 0.09% core CPI, and then a series of low 0.2s & 0.1s. So core is going up this summer.
  • Here is what I said about last month’s figures: https://mikeashton.wordpress.com/2017/02/15/summary-of-my-post-cpi-tweets-36/
  • 5 mins to CPI. Sources say the headline number is trading 243.34 (which would be -0.04% on headline) in the CPI derivs mkt.
  • core at 0.21%, higher than consensus expectations of 0.15% or so. Keeps y/y at 2.22%, down from 2.26%. But next month is an easy comp.
  • Monthly core CPI prints.

  • I don’t pay much attention to headline but it was a little high, y/y up to 2.74%. Only matters if it affects tenor of Fed discussion.
  • In major subgroups: Housing rose to 3.18% vs 3.12%. Need to see if that’s energy. Apparel fell back, as did health care.
  • w/in housing, Primary Rents slipped to 3.91% from 3.93%, Owner’s Equiv to 3.53% from 3.54%. So the housing bump was elsewhere.
  • Looks like the housing increase was mostly household energy, 4.46% from 3.51%. So no biggie as the kids say.
  • Apparel 0.42% vs 0.99%. The big jump last month was mostly reversed. Overall core services 3.1% and core goods dropped back to -0.5%
  • Last month the big story was that core goods had caused the jump in core CPI. Looks like these were mostly seasonal issues after all.
  • Transportation 6.3% vs 4.8%. That’s mostly gasoline. New & used cars slipped. But rising: parts, maintenance, insurance, airfares.
  • In Medical Care, big drop in medicinal drugs 4.19% vs 4.85%. Also drop in prof svcs (2.68% v 2.94%). THOSE are the one-offs this month.
  • Here are y/y med care & housing, source of the big upward pressure recently. But remember this month the housing is mostly energy.

  • Four more major subcategories. Recreation is the only one moving higher, but it’s a heterogeneous group & hard to decipher.

  • Quick estimate of Median is 0.21% m/m, 2.52% y/y, not quite a new high. Official figure will be out later.
  • Next month we should have core back over 2.3% and a shot at 2.4%, thanks to easy comp in March.
  • 10y inflation swaps still below current median inflation.

  • Mkt pretty confident in Fed: CPI mkt pricing: 2017 2.0%;2018 2.2%;then 2.2%, 2.1%, 2.2%, 2.2%, 2.3%, 2.4%, 2.5%, 2.7%, & 2027:2.5%.
  • This CPI report takes inflation off the boil, but not off the burner.
  • One more chart: weight of CPI categories over 3% inflation y/y.

Let’s face it. While this month’s CPI held some intrigue because of last month’s surprising spike, nothing about the figure was likely to change the outcome of today’s FOMC meeting and probably not the tenor of the statement or post-meeting presser. So, in that sense, this was a much less-significant report than last month’s release.

At the same time…let’s not lose sight of the fact that this was still an above-consensus CPI report. While the consensus was broadly correct that some of the jumps in core goods categories from last month were one-offs, and at least partially retraced this month, it’s still the case that y/y core inflation is going to keep rising through the summer merely on base effects. If the Fed wants to be hawkish and tighten more than the market currently expects (I think that nothing could be further from the truth, with Yellen at the helm, but she seems to dislike President Trump enough that she might forget some of her dovish leanings), then they will continue to have cover from inflation reports for a while.

Going forward from that, there are two inflation questions that will be resolved: (1) Will core goods recover and rise, indicating a broadening of inflation impulses that could produce a longer-tail upside? And (2) will housing inflation flatten out or decline since rent inflation is currently rising faster than even our most-generous models? If it does, then core inflation might stabilize near the current level, or even decline.

I have trouble figuring out what the mechanism would be for inflation to flatten out at these levels, from the macro-monetary perspective. Money growth remains brisk and higher interest rates should eventually goose velocity. I don’t see much prospect of money growth rolling over while banks are neither capital- nor reserve- constrained. And it’s hard to see interest rates heading back down while central banks shift into less-accommodative stances. I have more confidence in the macro-monetary (“top down”) model at longer time frames, and more confidence in the bottom-up analysis at shorter time frames. And for years they’ve told the same story: inflation should be rising, and it has. But there is a conflict between these perspectives that is coming later this year. How it resolves will be the story of the next 3-6 months.

%d bloggers like this: