Archive

Archive for the ‘Tweet Summary’ Category

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (August 2020)

August 12, 2020 1 comment

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors, issuers and risk managers with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments!

  • Well, it’s CPI day and I have to tell you I’m looking forward to this one and I’ll tell you why.
  • Used cars! The Black Book retention index jumped about 9% last month after 8.5% the prior month. There’s typically a 3-month lag before it gets into CPI, but w/ a big move it’s harder to say. Each of those jumps would be worth about 0.3% on core, and we have two of them coming.

  • That being said, (a) there is still one dip we haven’t seen yet so we COULD have a dip in used cars this month. It would be surprising, but it would mean we can prep for a couple of really good numbers. So I’m excited either way.
  • And it’s not just used cars. Now that things are opening up, we’re going to see pressures in other places. Medical care started to show some ups last month and I expect that to continue as hospitals are hurting for revenue.
  • Last month we also saw strong apparel, lodging away from home, and airfares, which were rebounding from the covid-induced swoon. I think that could continue, and it’s an interesting story line to watch.
  • On the other hand – this is next month’s story but college tuitions are likely to decline this year because colleges are giving discounts. Even though the product has changed in quality (e-learning not the same as in-person), the BLS has decided it can’t quality-adjust easily.
  • So CPI for college-tuition-and-fees – again, probably next month – will fall and then rebound hard next year. So that’s fun. It’s not right, but it’s okay, as the saying goes.
  • Shelter last month, ex-hotels, was soft. That’s the only fly in the inflationary ointment, but it’s a big one. So far it doesn’t look like rents are likely to decelerate much overall, nor housing prices fall – but if they do, that’s a big deal.
  • I will be looking at core-ex-housing to see if pressures are broadening, but looking at shelter b/c it’s a big, slow item. If shelter weakens appreciably, it will be news – historically, with the last recession being an exception, housing prices and rents almost never FALL.
  • But they can slow, and with incomes sketchy housing inflation probably SHOULD slow. If it doesn’t, that’s a real sign that the rising monetary tide is raising all assets. (And goods and services). FWIW, wages also aren’t slowing. Atlanta Fed wages are +3.8% y/y.
  • (There’s interesting stuff around the disconnect between wages and the unemployment rate right now, but I’ll save that for a blog post another time. Not really a CPI-day thing.)
  • Consensus today is for 0.2% on core CPI, but a soft 0.2% with y/y falling to 1.1%. I think there’s lots of upside to that if Used Cars pops, but a little downside if shelter is weak again. I’m in the “probably higher” camp.
  • Good luck! And if you’re curious about what an inflation guy does when it’s not CPI day, stop by Enduring Investments: http://enduringinvestments.com
  • Oh, yes.
  • I don’t think we need to worry much about the rounding this month. Core +0.6% m/m; y/y to 1.6% when it was expected to drop to 1.1%.
  • FWIW, that was rounded down. +0.62% m/m on core. Repeat: rounded down. I will have to check but that is the biggest monthly figure in decades.
  • I think I soiled myself.
  • There are going to be a lot of crazy charts like this one this month. This is the last 12 core CPI prints.

  • y/y core rose from 1.19% to 1.57%, in one month. Core goods were -1.10% y/y; now they are -0.5%. Core services were 1.90%; now they’re 2.3%.
  • Take that Keynesians. WHERE’S YOUR OUTPUT GAP MODEL NOW? …but I shouldn’t celebrate. All of those degrees…and poor Nomura forecasting outright deflation…
  • Now interestingly, Used Cars and Trucks was up, 2.33% m/m, but that’s not the big jump yet. (!)

  • Lodging Away from Home, another COVID-casualty, was +1.2% m/m. Same as last month. But the y/y is still -13.26% (was -13.92%).
  • Primary rents rebounded some, +0.19% vs +0.12% last month, and OER as well +0.21% from +0.09%. Those are m/m numbers, and the y/y are still softening though: 3.12% for primary rents and 2.80% for OER, down from 3.22%/2.84%. But not collapsing.
  • OK, I said I was going to be interested in core-ex-housing. It jumped from 0.35% y/y to +1.01% y/y. Now, that’s only the highest since March but again: the deflation dragon, if not slain, is pretty sick.
  • Apparel was +1.08% m/m, but y/y is still -6.4% (was -7.2%). Like the other belly-flop categories, there’s still a lot of recovery to come.
  • So how are the doctors doing? Medical Care was +0.41% m/m, but that actually dropped the y/y slightly to 5.02% from 5.08%. However, that’s mostly because Pharma remains weak.
  • CPI for Medicinal Drugs was flat again. +0.02% this month; -0.01% last month. The y/y is down to 1.1%.

  • But Physicians’ Services up to 2.58% y/y (up 0.67% this month)

  • And hospital services hanging out at around 5% y/y. Look, like many services these are all becoming more labor-intensive and that means…more expensive. Some of that might come back, some day.

  • Totally forgot airfares: +5.4% m/m after +2.6% m/m last month. But still down a lot from the peak. Here’s the y/y figure.

  • And a quick check of the markets: 10-year breakevens +3.5bps, kinda surprised it’s not more. 5y breakevens +5bps. Some of this might just be time for price discovery. I know when I was a CPI swaps dealer, it took some time before we knew wth was the right price.
  • BTW that core increase was the biggest monthly increase since 1991. That predates TIPS by 6 years.
  • Now, college tuition and fees rose to 2.09% y/y from 1.74% y/y. That’s interesting, as that serious ought to be declining next month. And for tuitions, that’s a largeish m/m change. Interesting.
  • Let’s see. Biggest m/m declines: misc personal goods (-41.7% annualized) and meats, poultry, fish & eggs (-36.9%, but it had been up a lot too).
  • The list of gains annualizing more than 10% has 14 categories. Includes motor vehicle insurance, car/truck rental, public transportation, used cars/trucks, communication, jewelry, footwear, lodging away from home…
  • Now, those who live by Median CPI ought to also die by Median CPI. I’ll convert you all, eventually. Median this month will be something like +0.21%, because it ignores the upside long tails like it did the downside ones. y/y will actually decline to 2.56%
  • The message there is just that the underlying trends are pretty stable. But it’s not insignificant that the tails shifted to the right side from the left side. As I’ve said before, that’s sort of what infl looks like in practice, just as disinflation has one-offs to the left.
  • Health insurance y/y is a little softer, down to 18.7% y/y from 19.4%. So we got that going for us.

  • This is the distribution of y/y changes in the CPI. There’s still a big left tail anchor which is why core is below median. But this is a much more balanced distribution than it has been in a while.

  • And here’s the weight of categories going up by more than 2.5% y/y. The weight is the highest since July 2008.

  • That doesn’t look very deflationary to me.
  • Putting together the four-pieces charts and then I’ll wrap up.
  • Piece 1 – food and energy. With all of the wild swings, it’s net-net kinda boring.

  • Piece 2, core goods. This was the piece that was getting a wind behind it because of trade frictions when the crisis hit. Big bounce this month. Much of that is autos, but as I pointed out early: the BIG jump in car prices hasn’t hit the data yet.

  • Piece 3, core services less rent of shelter. Also a big recovery, and some of this is airfares. Some also is medical care. But there are a number of other categories contributing here. Still kind of trendless last 5y, overall.

  • Piece 4, the biggest and slowest piece, and looks scary. Until you remember this includes hotels (lodging away from home). If you take that out, shelter has decelerated some but not a lot, and certainly not in a disturbing way like this appears. Don’t project this!

  • OK to sum up. I saw someone call this a “noisy” report. Well, only in the sense of clanging cymbals. The data here all swung in one direction – but there really weren’t a lot of surprises, per se. The only surprise was the synchony of the surprises to one side.
  • As I said up top, we still have a couple of +0.3% boosts (maybe +0.2% if we’re ahead of mode) coming from used cars. And a lot of the beaten-down categories haven’t really recovered (apparel, etc) fully.
  • THAT’S what’s surprising. This wasn’t the left tail snapping back, much. This was a much broader advance than the decline had been. The decline had been 4 categories: lodging AFH, used cars, airfares, apparel. Way more here.
  • There are lots of bumps ahead, including the question of whether home prices and rents decelerate when and if incomes decline. We aren’t seeing that yet. And with M2 growing at 23% per year, it’s hard to believe asset prices can decline very much. Including housing.
  • The fun thing to think about is: what is happening at the Fed today? Are they clapping wildly, that they succeeded in pushing prices up? Or are they somber, wondering if they might have overdone it? Or are they focusing on median CPI and saying, meh?
  • My guess is that there’s a bit of nervousness. The Fed wants to overshoot 2%, but they don’t want to put it at 6%. I’ve said for a long time: creating inflation is easy. Creating A LITTLE inflation is hard.
  • Well, that was fun. Thanks for tuning in. I’ll put a summary on my blog relatively shortly. Again, if today’s number makes you think ‘hey, maybe we should talk to an inflation guy and see if he can help us’, stop by our website: https://enduringinvestments.com Have a nice day.

I don’t know whether to be exhausted or energized. I think I’ll go with energized, because this is not likely to be the last surprise in inflation prints. We are entering a period, not only of higher inflation (probably), but also much higher inflation volatility. That’s important, because a key underpinning of the valuation argument for stocks and bonds is that inflation is not only low, it’s low and stable and therefore can be ignored in calculations. But if inflation is volatile, and especially if it’s high and volatile, then  companies and investors need to include it in their calculus. And if the inflation factor ends up becoming significant again, after more than a decade of irrelevance, then it means that (a) stocks and bonds will become increasingly correlated and (b) stock and bond valuations will be lower.

Now, I don’t know if the markets really understand what’s going on. In fact, this number was so outside of expectations I think that investors just dismissed it as a one-off, like April’s number. But it’s not. This was not just a snapback of the depressed categories; indeed, most of the categories that were depressed because of Covid (lodging away from home, airfares, e.g.) are still depressed although they’ve rebounded a little. This was much broader than that. But investors have pushed 10-year breakevens up only 3-4bps, to 1.66%. Stocks are soaring, and 10-year nominal yields are a mere 3.5bps higher. Commodities are flat. Gold, after a bloodbath yesterday, is flat today. The only way those reactions make sense is if investors are missing the significance.

When the unemployment rate shoots higher, then you can understand a positive market reaction because investors have come to count on the Fed supporting markets in that circumstance. But that reasoning doesn’t make sense here. Nothing about a 7.2% annualized rate of inflation (0.6% * 12) would make the Fed eager to add more liquidity. Ergo, it must be that investors just don’t care about the inflation numbers, or they think this is a random miss.

They should care. This isn’t a one-standard-deviation miss; it’s the biggest monthly print in thirty years and there was no big outlier. While it doesn’t guarantee that inflation is heading higher, the question is whether this print is consistent with our a priori model of the world.

If you’re a Keynesian, the answer is absolutely not. So economists who are output-gap focused are going to say that this number doesn’t matter; it’s ‘quirky’ or ‘noisy’ or ‘measurement error’; the output gap is going to drag down inflation. Maybe that’s why investors are nonchalant about this…because they’re being told by the bow-tie set to look through it.

But if you’re a monetarist, this is entirely consistent with your a priori model. The only surprising thing about this is that it is happening so soon. I was thinking we would see inflation rise starting in Q4 and it would get messy in 2021. I might have to move up the timetable. Because this number is entirely consistent with my model, I’m much less sanguine. This might be only the first shot over the bow… Indeed, over the next several months I can say that since we are confident that used car prices are going to add a lot to core inflation, we will probably have at least one or two more prints of 0.4%-0.5% on core over the next three months. If we get 0.4%, 0.2%, 0.4%, then in three months core CPI will be back to 2.25% y/y, and that with unemployment still in the high-single or low-double-digits. And it could actually be worse than that. Without home prices collapsing, it’s hard to see it being much better than that and absolutely no way to see how prices (or even the inflation rate) could be lower than that unless something really, really weird happens.

Well, 2020 is the year of really, really weird so I suppose I will never say never. But inflation hedges remain super cheap; if you’ve been waiting to scoop them up I can’t see any argument for waiting any more.

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (July 2020)

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors, issuers and risk managers with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments!

  • Welcome to CPI day from the Rocky Mountains! Inflation indicators are getting more and more important these days, and today’s number will be interesting as always.
  • First, let me mention that I will be on @TDANetwork with @OJRenick today at 9:15ET to discuss the CPI and other inflation items. Tune in!
  • In this month’s CPI, we will probably continue to see some of the data collection issues from the last few months, but fewer. As the US has opened back up, the readings should start being cleaner. So the volatility we see will start to represent actual volatility in pricing.
  • I think we should continue to be cognizant of the underlying context, and that is that M2 growth in the US is at all-time records. Can we have 23% money growth and no inflation?

  • Keynesians would say yes – in fact, with the massive output gap, we should be in outright deflation. There may be some nuance (inflation anchoring keeps it from happening immediately), but the sign is clear.
  • Monetarists would say that after velocity corrects the unusual, huge precautionary demand for cash balances (lowering velocity), we should see problematic inflation. How much? Hard to say, but I’ll say I’m not aware of a society that has had 20% m2 growth and NOT had inflation.
  • So far, the monetarists are winning. While core inflation has dipped the last few months, it’s all in the ‘left tail’ of the distribution: used cars, airfares, lodging away from home, and apparel account for it all. Median inflation has barely budged.
  • So the story going forward is that we are going to eventually see a bounce in those tail items, so if we’re going to get deflation we need to see broader deceleration in prices.
  • The consensus today is for 0.1 m/m on the core CPI. That seems low to me. Unless something weird happens with primary rents and OER and they start to slow markedly, any rebound in those tail items is going to take inflation up. But we will see, in just a few minutes. Good luck!
  • Higher than expected core: +0.19% m/m, +1.19% y/y. As I noted up top, that’s not super surprising actually.

  • Sorry – erratum: seasonally adjusted core was +0.235, not 0.19%. So almost gave us a double-tick surprise.
    • In some of the unusuals from past months, yes we’re seeing corrections: Airfares +2.60% m/m (last month -4.88%); Lodging Away from Home +1.21% (last month -1.53%). Used Cars still soft, -1.19%. That’s actually surprising.
  • I suppose it is just in the lag, but used car prices rebounded in a major way in the private surveys (see chart). the Black Book index is higher than before Covid.

  • Interestingly, the upside core surprise happened DESPITE softness in primary rents (+0.12%, 3.22% y/y vs 3.48%) and OER (+0.09%, 2.84% y/y vs 3.06%)
  • Seeing strength in medical care, not surprisingly. That’s been hard to survey over the last couple of months. Doctors +0.45% m/m, 2.10% y/y (was 1.80); Hospitals +0.37% m/m, 5.29% y/y (was 4.86%) Pharma still soft, flat this mo but y/y up to 1.38% vs 0.97%
  • Forgot to mention Apparel, that other one-off. +1.66% this month, though still down hard y/y.
  • Hospital Services y/y

  • Core ex-housing rose slightly, to +0.35% y/y from +0.29% y/y. Still very low, but I suspect the lows are in.
  • Although this is an upside surprise, core still fell vs last month on a y/y basis because we rolled off a +0.28% from last June. Core goods were -1.1% vs -1.0% last month, core services +1.9% vs +2.0% last month (y/y). So there’s still some downward pressure. But it’s turning.
  • I’m afraid this is going to be abbreviated this month as I need to go get ready for @TDANetwork. I’ll be on at about 9:15 ET. Later I’ll update the four-pieces charts.
  • Bottom-lining it: the monetarists win another round as the broad deflation Keynesians would predict is nowhere in evidence. Some of the one-offs are correcting. We do need to keep an eye on the softening in rents.
  • NONE of this will bother the Fed yet…I doubt any of them got out of bed for this number. Thanks for tuning in!

Today’s CPI examination is somewhat abbreviated as I am on ‘vacation’ and my inspection of the report was interrupted by my TDA Network appearance. We’ll be back to normal-length next month. The basic story for the June CPI core inflation figure is a bit of a return to the mean, with most of the left-tail items (with the exception, only temporary, of used cars) rising and retracing some of the dramatic declines we saw in March, April, and May and at the same time a bit of softening of rents. I think the rental softness is also temporary, and tied to a lack of traffic over the last few months – but that’s the only potential fly in the ointment.

The takeaway for this month is really provided by the chart of the last 12 months’ core CPI print, the second one above. Heading into COVID, core CPI was printing around 0.2%-0.25% fairly consistently. March, April, and May were deep exceptions, but June is back to the former trend. To be fair, median CPI this month was very low, at +0.12% m/m and “only” 2.60% y/y. That deceleration was tied to softness in South and West regional Owners’ Equivalent Rent indices, which as I said would surprise me if it was repeated. Rents had recently retreated to our model, and have now slipped below (see chart below).


So, is a dramatic acceleration in inflation evident in the data? Not yet, although the acceleration in M2, coupled with my conviction that the precautionary demand for cash balances will eventually relax, makes me confident that we will see that in the quarters to come. But if we can’t say that breakout inflation is here, neither can we say that there is the least sign of deflation in these figures. Again, if the Keynesians are right, then the huge output gap means that aggregate demand will be insufficient to keep prices up, and deflation will ensue. In the Keynesian world, the only reason this hasn’t happened yet is that inflation expectations are well-anchored or, in other words, merchants haven’t caught on yet that they can’t charge what they were previously charging. In the monetarist mindset, the fact that there is far more money in bank accounts than there was just a few months ago means that eventually the nominal price of goods will be bid up since the price is after all just an exchange rate (of dollars for stuff), and when there are many more dollars then the price of those dollars declines (the price of stuff rises). The reason inflation hasn’t happened yet, according to this view, is that people are clutching nervously onto those cash balances, rather than spending it.

But there are signs that nervousness is ebbing – such as in the price of automobiles and many online goods. If the country lurches back into lockdowns, and the recovery turns back into a deeper recession, then that nervousness may continue for longer. American consumers, though, suck at saving and big cash balances and high savings rates are not usually persistent.

Categories: CPI, Tweet Summary

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (June 2020)

June 10, 2020 8 comments

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors, issuers and risk managers with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments!

  • It’s #CPI day again! These days it seems we live a year in every month, and from a data perspective that’s kinda true. There used to be months when there were no truly surprising data points. Here is my walk-up.
  • Before I do, let me invite folks to take a look at our newly renovated website at https://enduringinvestments.com. It’s like we finally made it into 2018!
  • Anyway, nowadays those data points that used to be surprising every few months come about once every ten minutes or so. Will CPI be one of them? It’s certainly been an…interesting…number over the past few months.
  • The BLS has had to wrestle with collection issues, such as the fact that in the teeth of the crisis they didn’t want to be placing a burden on medical care professionals to respond to a survey. So measuring prices was difficult.
  • And of course the BLS also recently had the issue with coding Unemployment, because we’ve never had a situation like this and so the book doesn’t explain what to do! CPI has some of those too.
  • There was also a much greater dispersion than usual in prices collected, because of wildly different circumstances at each outlet. Lots and lots of craziness. But the net was that we were -0.10% on core in March, -0.45% in April.
  • Here is one example, from this month, that will be important in Used Cars. The Mannheim index had a massive jump, while the Black Book index slipped slightly further. So how do you forecast CPI for Used Cars??

  • It appears that while used car prices rebounded at the wholesale market, they didn’t at the retail level. I think that, and all of the rebound stories, are “yet.” But who knows what that means for this month.
  • I think we ought to get a healthy rebound in Lodging Away from home, which has fallen 14% or so over the last couple of months. And Airfares. But maybe not until next month.
  • Here’s the thing. From the top down and bottom up, it looks very likely that prices will be accelerating going forward. Clearly, everything is getting more labor-intensive and we’re re-onshoring cheap overseas production in some cases. And here’s the top-down case, which is M2.

  • The rise in M2 is unprecedented, and while a near-term precautionary demand for money will depress velocity, the Fed is in a real corner when velocity rebounds, and it will.
  • But that’s not today. Today the consensus forecast is for flat m/m figures on both core and headline. Food will be a big positive contributor, energy a negative contributor (probably) for another month. Net result: wild guesses.
  • To me, it feels like we’re due for an upside surprise. I would guess Medical Care is due for something funky. But I don’t make forecasts in normal times; sure as heck am not going to do it NOW. Good luck folks.
  • It’s almost creepy. Core CPI was very close to flat, at -0.06% m/m and 1.24% y/y. That’s ridiculously close to forecasts given all of the difficulties.
  • I forgot to mention too that the range in forecasts was not all that wide either…there wasn’t anyone with a -0.3% or +0.3% forecast on core. Which is wild!
  • Last 12 core CPIs:

  • Food and Beverages was (only) +0.72% m/m, raising the y/y to 3.88% from 3.39%. I don’t normally focus on non-core items but this is one where we’ve seen massive moves. So I was surprised we didn’t see more.
  • Here is the y/y change in food & beverages. Not at all bad yet. Food at home is +4.8% y/y, but still not as high as those prior peaks. More coming I am afraid.

  • On to more interesting items. Used Cars and Trucks were -0.39% m/m, which weirdly raises the y/y figure to -0.37% from -0.75% last month. But that’s part of the weakness in m/m core. Black Book was closer, as it has been.
  • But used car prices will come back, so get your deals while you can. Wholesale prices have largely rebounded to the pre-covid levels. Retail will get there, once people are shopping.
  • Overall, core goods fell to -1% y/y from -0.9%, and core services to 2.0% from 2.2%.
  • BTW used cars correction: -0.35% this month, not -0.39%, on the m/m. My error.
  • On rents, Primary Rents were unchanged y/y at 3.49%. Owners’ Equivalent was approximately unch at 3.06% vs 3.07%.
  • BUT Lodging Away from Home fell further. -1.53% m/m, bringing y/y to -15.06% from -13.91%. That’s a bit at odds with what I’ve seen personally, but a big reason for the weakness in core.
  • Also airfares was -4.9% m/m, clearly at odds with what is actually happening to city-pairs prices. This must have something to do with when they collected the data, or perhaps there are fewer first class seats and that’s affecting the avg.
  • Y/y the BLS says -29% fall in airfares, which itself doesn’t seem too crazy, so maybe this month is some kind of catch-up. But again, airfares are certainly going to rise – unless we simply forget about social distancing and start running full planes again.
  • So on core, it seems the usual suspects again this month. Rents fine, airfares and used cars and lodging away from home big losses.
  • How about Medical Care? m/m +0.49%, to 4.90% y/y from 4.81% y/y. Pharma flat, but y/y up to 0.93% from 0.78%.
  • Doctor’s Services finally showed some life as doctors’ offices reopen (another place we’re going to see increases if they can take fewer patients, but maybe it’s not nice to do it right away). +0.65% m/m, to 1.80% y/y from 1.23%.
  • But Hospital Services only +0.11% m/m, and the y/y declined to 4.86% from 5.21%. Again, that’s weird in a time of Covid. I think while the last couple of CPI reports were pretty clean, we’re starting to see some stale prices affect the numbers.
  • I’m not saying that because of the overall result…flat core cpi m/m was about right. But it’s WHERE we are seeing some of these things that’s weird.
  • Now, I totally buy Apparel at -2.29% m/m, -7.90% y/y. That makes total sense to me and less clear that turns into a positive number. We’re not going to start making apparel again in the US. I think we’ll get back to flat prices eventually.
  • OK this is interesting. Alcoholic beverages is 1% of the CPI, but this is Alcoholic Beverages at Home since the other part doesn’t make sense. Note that last two peaks were around big recessions? Expect more upside here! Surprised it isn’t already higher.

  • Biggest core declines on the month (annualized monthly change): Car Insurance -67%, Public Transportation -37%, Car/Truck Rental -34%, Women’s Apparel -30%, Men’s Apparel -29%, Lodging AFH -16.8%, Footwear -16%.
  • Biggest gainers, other than Meat, Poultry, Fish, and Eggs (+55% annualized) and Dairy (+12.6%): Recreation (+11.1%) and Motor Vehicle Parts/Equipment (+10.6%) Guess if you’re not buying new cars, you’re fixing the old one.
  • FWIW, Median is going to be very interesting this month. It’s probably going to be around +0.27% ish. Likely to be the highest since January. That’s yet another reminder this inflation ‘slowdown’ is ALL IN THE LEFT TAIL. Big drops in just a few categories.
  • However, one of those left-tail items is not shelter. So, core ex-shelter is now the lowest since well before the GFC. We are nearing non-shelter deflation. Get ready for the agitated headlines.

  • Again, worth remembering is that that dramatic picture is ALL IN THE LEFT TAIL.
  • Hey, let’s talk about the Fed for a second and then I want to turn to Recreation. This number will not change – and actually, no number would – the Fed’s trajectory. They’re going to stay easy, easy, easy. Even when inflation signs emerge.
  • IN FACT, this dip in prices will help the Fed ignore the acceleration, because they’ll say it’s just a rebound. But the key will be that the acceleration will NOT just be in the tail, bouncing back, but the middle of the distribution.
  • So, the Recreation category (5.8% of CPI) rose 0.88% m/m, pushing y/y to 2.11% vs 0.94% previous. Larger jump than Food & Beverages.
  • In the subcategories of Recreation, the biggest jump by far was in Other recreation services, which was +4.99% y/y versus +1.61% last month. Why?
  • In the sub-sub-categories below Other recreation services, we have Admissions rising 3.63% vs 1.23%. But the BIG increase was “club memberships for shopping clubs, fraternal or other organizations, or participant sports fees”. +7.34% y/y vs +2.55%. Discuss.
  • OK 4 pieces of CPI. Actually 5 today. First Food & Energy. Thanks to Food, not as bad by now as I’d thought we’d have been.

  • Piece 2 is core goods. Apparel, e.g.. Not surprising we’re down here, although Pharma (only +0.9% y/y) continues to surprise me. Pharma will rise once we start onshoring APIs. In the meantime, core goods is weak, but not sure it gets much weaker.

  • Core services. Again, polluted by lodging away from home and airfares. This will snap back over the next few months, because I don’t think Medical Care is about to plunge and it’s steadier than Lodging AFH and Airfares.

  • Piece 4, which COULD be alarming: rent of shelter. But, of course, this is all Lodging AFH (I mistakenly put this in core services less ROS in my prior tweet!). So let’s look at piece 4a, that breaks out the stable part of rents.

  • There is nothing surprising here happening to OER. And in fact, home prices seem to be holding up just fine and foot traffic has been increasing. In uncertain times, what’s better than your own home? If you expect deflation, you better find it here. And you won’t.

  • 10y Breakevens today +3.5bps. That’s interesting, and it suggests people are looking past the current figures. But 10y Breaks are still at 1.28%, with implied core inflation well below 2% for a decade.
  • But it’s still a really big bet that deflationary forces will win. And that seems increasingly unlikely.
  • Breakevens are not as big a bet at 1.28% as they were at 0.94% when I wrote this: https://mikeashton.wordpress.com/2020/03/11/the-big-bet-of-10-year-breakevens-at-0-94/
  • OK, that’s it for now. I look forward to the days when all of the one-offs are done. One last comment: if median CPI is in fact +0.27%, then y/y Median would rise. In fact, anything above 0.21% m/m would mean y/y increases from its current 2.70%…
  • I will publish a summary of all these tweets later. Thanks for tuning in. Be sure to visit the website at https://enduringinvestments.com and tell me what you think about the new look.
  • Oh, one more fun chart. Here is the Apparel series. Clothing prices in the US are now down to levels we haven’t seen since 1988. I can finally break out that old tie. Oh wait, it’s price not fashion.

Another month, another set of crazy figures from Airfares, Lodging Away from Home, Apparel, and Cars. Outside of those, there really haven’t been many big surprises. I guess it’s surprising booze inflation isn’t higher yet. But if we were entering into a deflationary period, we wouldn’t see core decelerating only because of left-tail events, and we wouldn’t see Median CPI accelerating. This really gives every sign of just being a set of one-offs that will pass out of the data before long and be replaced by the true underlying trend. Prior to COVID-19, that trend was a gradual but unmistakable acceleration in inflation, so in my view that’s probably the best outcome you can hope for if you are a bond investor: that we settle back to something like 3% in median inflation and 2.25-2.5% in core inflation. There is as yet no sign of the collapse in housing that we would need to usher in another Depression-like scenario, and for all the errors the Fed made back then the one they have not made this time, indubitably, is the error of failing to add enough liquidity. Indeed, the error they’ve made this time is that they have added far, far too much liquidity and there is no good way to remove it.

That isn’t this month’s story, and it isn’t this quarter’s story. Short-maturity TIPS, not surprisingly, trade at very low implied inflation rates even though energy prices have aggressively rebounded – right now, TIPS carry is awful and if you own a short TIPS bond you’re not looking at next year’s inflation. Beyond the front end of the TIPS curve, though, pricing of inflation-linked bonds relative to nominal bonds is almost comical. Yes, real yields are very low and it’s hard to love TIPS just for TIPS. I don’t understand, though, why TIPS aren’t currently beloved compared to all forms of fixed-rate debt. Some of it is indexed money, but I don’t understand why the indexed money is insisting on smashing into a wall. This will all become obvious eventually, and people will look back, and everyone will remember how they were very bullish on breakevens and can’t believe how everyone else messed up. And everyone will be an inflation expert.

Today’s figure doesn’t mean anything to the Fed, as I said before. Well before this all happened, Chairman Powell had effectively abandoned the inflation mandate. Late last year, he’d declared “So, I think we would need to see a really significant move up in inflation that’s persistent before we even consider raising rates to address inflation concerns.” And then, on February 11th in front of the House Financial Services Committee Powell, in response to a question from Congressperson Ayanna Pressley (D-MA) about whether the central bank could ensure economic conditions such that “anyone who wants to work and can work will have a job available to them,” Powell responded that the Fed will ‘never’ declare victory on full employment. Not a word about inflation in his response. With Unemployment in the teens right now, I think we can safely say it will be a very long time before the Fed makes inflation its primary worry.

But, I think eventually they will.

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (May 2020)

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors, issuers and risk managers with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments!

  • Once again CPI day, and unlike last month where expectations were very low, it seems people think they have a firmer grasp of inflation this month. Ha!
  • I suppose that’s relative, but while I think there will be some interesting stories today I wouldn’t read much into the near-term data. Some things we know will be happening just aren’t happening yet.
  • Some examples include hotels, food away from home, rent of residence, medical care…all of these have serious upward pressures going forward, but not clear today.
  • I’ll talk about these as we go today. The consensus forecast for core is -0.2%, dropping y/y core to 1.7% from 2.1%. Last April – so sweet, so long ago – was +0.198% on core so ordinarily we’d be expecting a small y/y acceleration today.
  • But remember that last month, median inflation was pretty much normal. All of the movement in core was in lodging away from home, airfares, and apparel.
  • I don’t know about apparel, but I doubt the other two have fallen as far this month. Surveys of used cars, another typical volatility source, have plunged though. Usually takes a couple months for that to come into the CPI, but with a big move like that, it might.
  • On the other hand, prices for medical care were virtually ignored in the survey for last month’s release. If they start surveying those more ambitiously, that’s going to be additive. No question in the medium-term, medical care prices are going up.
  • Rents will be very interesting. So, if someone skips a rent payment how the BLS treats it depends on whether the landlord expects to collect it eventually, some of it, or none of it.
  • Rent-skipping isn’t yet unusually prevalent, and the threat that Congress could declare a rent holiday will mean that NEW rents are definitely going to be higher (this is a new risk for a landlord). Remember it’s rents that drive housing inflation, not home prices.
  • Neither effect is likely appearing yet, but be careful of that number today. In fact, as I said up top, be careful of ALL of the numbers today!
  • In the medium-term, inflation is lots more likely than deflation because there is much more money out there chasing fewer goods and services (20% y/y rise in M2, better than 50% annualized q/q). But today?
  • And while no one will be surprised with a low number today, almost everyone would be shocked with a high number. But with a lot of volatility, a wider range of outcomes in BOTH directions becomes possible.
  • In other words, HUGE error bars on today’s number, which SHOULD mean we take it with a grain of salt and wait for a few more numbers. Markets aren’t good with that approach. OK, that’s it for the walk-up. Hold onto your hats folks. May get bumpy.
  • Core CPI fell -0.448%, meaning that it was very close to -0.5% m/m. The y/y fell to 1.44%. The chart looks like a lot of the other charts we’re seeing these days. But of course devil will be in the details.

  • Core goods -0.9% y/y from -0.2%; core services 2.2% from 2.8%.
  • CPI for used cars and trucks, coming off +0.82% last month, turned a -0.39% this month. That’s not super surprising. I suspect going forward that rental fleets will shrink (meaning more used cars) since most cars are rented from airports.

  • Lodging Away from Home again plunged, -7.1% after -6.8% last month. That’s a little surprising. In my own personal anecdotal observation, hotel prices in some places went up last month, although to be fair that’s forward. TODAY’S hotel prices are still being discounted.
  • However Primary rents were +0.20% after +0.30% last month. Y/Y slid to 3.49% from 3.67%. Owners’ Equivalent Rent was +0.17% vs 0.26% last month; y/y fell to 3.07% from 3.22%.
  • I would not expect any serious decline in rents going forward. It’s housing stock vs number of households, and if we’re trying to spread out that means MORE households if anything. Also, as noted earlier I expect landlords to raise rents to recapture ‘jubilee risk.’
  • Apparel was again down hard, -4.7% m/m. That’s not surprising to me. Transportation down -5.9% m/m, again no real surprise with gasoline. But Food & Beverages higher, up 1.40% m/m. That’s not surprising at all, if you’ve been buying groceries!
  • Still some oddness in Medical Care. Pharma was -0.13% m/m, down to +0.78% y/y from +1.30% last month. Doctors’ Services -0.08%. Both of those make little sense to me. But hospital services +0.50% m/m, pushing y/y to 5.21% from 4.37%. That part makes perfect sense!
  • Hospital Services Y/Y. Expect that one to keep going up. Overall, of the 8 major subsectors only Food & Energy, Medical Care, and Education/Communication were up m/m.

  • Core ex-housing fell to +0.6% y/y, vs +1.45% last month. That’s the lowest since…well, just 2017. The four-pieces chart is going to be interesting. As I keep saying though, the real story is in 2-3 months once things have settled and there’s actual transactions again.

  • Little pause here because some of the BLS series aren’t updated. I was looking at the -100% fall in Leased Cars and Trucks…and the BLS simply didn’t report a figure for that. Which is odd.
  • …doesn’t look like a widespread problem so we’ll continue. A quick look forward at Median – there’s going to be more of an effect this month but going to be up by roughly +0.15% depending on where the regional housing indices fall.
  • That will drop y/y median to 2.70% or so from 2.80%. You’ll see when we look at the distribution later, this is still largely a left-tail event. The middle of the distribution is shrugging slightly lower. Again, it’s early.
  • Biggest core category decliners: Car and Truck Rental, Public Transportation, Motor Vehicle Insurance, Lodging Away from Home, Motor Vehicle Fees (sensing a trend?) and some Apparel subcategories.
  • Only gainer above 10% annualized in core was Miscellaneous Personal Goods. But in food: Fresh fruits/veggies, Dairy, Other Food at Home, Processed Fruits/Veggies, Cereals/baking products, Nonalcoholic beverages, Meats/poultry/fish/eggs.
  • Gosh, I didn’t mention airfares, -12.4% m/m, -24.3% y/y. Some of that is jet fuel pass through. But it’s also definitely not going to last. Fewer seats and more inelastic travelers (business will be first ones back on planes) will mean lots higher ticket prices.
  • The airfares thing is a good thought experiment. Airlines have narrow margins. Now they take out middle seats. What happens to the fares they MUST charge? Gotta go up, a lot. Not this month though!

  • I’ll take a moment for that reminder – people tend to confuse price and quantity effects here, which is one reason everyone expects massive deflation. There is a massive drop in consumption, but that doesn’t mean a massive drop in prices.
  • Indeed, if it means that the marginal price-elastic buyer in each market is exiting long-term, it makes prices more likely to rise than to fall going forward. Producers only cut prices IF cutting prices is likely to induce more buyers. Today, they won’t.

  • 10-year breakevens are roughly unchanged from before the number. If anything, slightly higher. I think that’s telling – they’re already pricing in so little inflation that it’s getting hard to surprise them lower.
  • 10y CPI swaps, vs median CPI. Little disconnect.

  • Little delay from updating this chart. OER dropped to the lowest growth rate in a few years. But it’s not out of line with underlying fundamentals.

  • To be fair, underlying fundamentals take a while to work through housing, but lots of other places we’ve seen sudden moves. The only sudden move we have to be wary of is in rents if Congress declares a rent holiday.
  • Under BLS collection procedures, if rent isn’t collected but landlord expects to collect in the future, it goes in normally. If landlord expects a fraction, that is taken into effect. If landlord doesn’t expect to collect, then zero.
  • …which means that if Congress said “in June, no one needs to pay rent,” you’d get a zero, massive decline in rents…followed by a massive increase the next time they paid. That would totally muck up CPI altogether, and I would hope they would do some intervention pricing.
  • So that’s a major wildcard. To say nothing of the huge effect it would have on the economy. Let’s hope Congress leaves it to individual landlords to work it out with tenants, or at worst there’s a Rental Protection Program where the taxpayers pay the rent instead of the tenant.
  • OK time for four-pieces charts. For those new to this, these four pieces add up to the CPI and they’re all between 20% and 33% of the CPI.

  • Piece 1: Food and Energy. Actually could have been worse. Energy down huge, Food up huge (+1.5% m/m). But this is the volatile part. Interesting for a change as energy is reversing!

  • Piece 2, core goods. We went off script here. But partly, this is because the medicinal drugs component is lagging what intuition tells us it should be doing.

  • I said offscript for core goods. Here’s the model. We were expecting to be back around 0% over the next year, but not -1%.

  • Piece 3, core services less rent of shelter. This was in the process of moving higher before the virus. Medical Care pieces will keep going higher but airfares e.g. are under serious pressure. Again, I think that’s temporary.

  • Piece 4: rent of shelter. The most-stable piece; this would be alarming except that a whole lot of it is lodging away from home. I’ve already showed you OER. It has slowed, but it will take a collapse in home prices to get core deflation in the US. Doesn’t seem imminent.

  • Last two charts. First one shows the distribution of price changes. Most of what is happening in CPI right now is really big moves way out to the left. That’s why Median is declining slowly but Core is dropping sharply. It’s the tails.

  • And another way to look at the same thing, the weight of categories that are inflating above 3% per year. Still close to half. MOST prices aren’t falling and many aren’t even slowing. Some, indeed, are rising. This does not look like a deflationary outcome looming.

  • Overall summary – much softer figure than last month, but still pretty concentrated in the things we knew would be weak. A few minor surprises. But for us to get a real deflationary break, another big shoe needs to drop.
  • With money supply soaring and supply chains creaking, any return to normal economic activity is going to result in bidding for scarce supplies with plentiful money. You already see that in food, the one thing it’s easy to buy right now. That’s the dynamic to fear when we reopen.
  • And, lastly. I’ve made the point many times recently: inflation hedges are priced so that if you believe in deflation you should STILL bet on inflation because you don’t get any payoff if you’re right about deflation.
  • That’s all for today. Stop by our *new* website at https://enduringinvestments.com and let us know what you think. It needed a facelift! Good luck out there.

I think the key point this month is the point I made up top: we always need to be wary of one month’s data from any economic release. It’s important to remember that the release isn’t the actual situation, it’s a measurement of the actual situation and any measurement has a margin for error. All of these data need to be viewed through the lens of ‘does this change my null hypothesis of what was happening,’ and if the error bars are large enough then the answer almost always should be ‘no.’

However, markets don’t usually act like that. Although there’s not a lot of information in the economic data these days the markets act like there is. (I was, however, pleased to see the TIPS market not overreacting for a change.) Let’s look at this data for what it is: right now, the one thing we know for sure is that it’s hard to buy anything at all. Economic activity is a fraction of what it was before the lockdowns took effect – but that affects economic quantities transacted (GDP), not prices. We need to get back to something like normal business before we know where prices are going to reach equilibrium. From these levels, my answer is that in most cases the equilibrium will almost assuredly be higher. I think most consumer-to-consumer services are going to end up being a lot more labor-intensive, which is good for labor’s share of national income but bad for prices: declining productivity shows up in higher prices. And there’s lots more money out in the system. While some of this is because companies drew quickly on their bank lines lest those lines be pulled like they were in 2008-2009, a great deal of it is because the government is spending enormous sums (a lot of it helicopter money) and the Fed is financing that by buying the debt being issued. So while M2 growth probably won’t end up at 20% y/y for a long period, I think the best we can hope for is that it goes flat. That is, I think the money is here to stay.

Monetary velocity is falling, and in fact the next print or two are going to be incredibly low. Precautionary cash balances ballooned. But once the economy opens again, those precautionary balances will drop back to normal-ish and the money will still be there. It’s a cocktail for higher inflation, to be sure. The only question is how much higher.

Over the next few months, the inflation numbers will be hard to interpret. What’s temporary, and what’s permanent? Keep in mind that inflation is a rate of change. So hotel prices have plunged. Gasoline prices have plunged. But unless they continue to plunge, you don’t have deflation. You have a one-off that will wash out of the data eventually. If hotel prices retrace half of their plunge, that will be represented by a m/m increase from these levels. Airfares will end up higher than they were before the crisis, but even if they didn’t they’d likely be higher from here. The real question is whether the one-offs spread much farther than apparel/airfares/lodging away from home. So far, they’ve spread a little, but not a lot. We’re nowhere close to deflation, and I don’t think we’re going to be.

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (April 2020)

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments (updated site coming soon).

  • CPI Day! I have to be honest – with the markets closed and this number likely to not have a lot of meaning, I almost skipped doing this this morning. But, thanks to M2, lots more people are suddenly listening so…obviously CPI is starting to be important. So let’s try.
  • The consensus for today, to the extent “consensus” means anything, is for -0.3% headline and +0.1% on core. But these are even more guesses than usual.
  • The BLS stopped taking prices a couple of weeks ago. That will have less effect than if that had happened a few years ago, b/c they ‘survey’ some prices using database downloads from retailers e.g. apparel.
  • But it still means that we don’t know what they’ll do about missing prices. Normally the BLS imputes an estimated figure for an item based on similar items…but if whole groups of items or categories are missing, less clear. Do they assume zero? Prior trend?
  • I actually think that this number won’t have too many of those problems but there will be some and next month will be very odd – and some chance they don’t publish at all because they can’t get statistically significant data.
  • In the meantime…remember we are coming off of recent strong data. Core was 2.37% y/y last month, and in general has headed higher. Before this, I was expecting 2.5% core by summer. Now that will take longer! (You can imply the word “maybe” before every statement this month.)
  • Lodging Away from Home is one place we’ll surely see an effect this month, and airfares, but beyond that who knows. And we are dropping off a weak +0.16% from last March so the core y/y figure might even stay steady. Or it could drop 0.3%. Who knows.
  • What we DO know is headline inflation is going to fall and in a month or 2 will show negative changes, which will prompt “DEFLATION!” screams. But headline just follows gasoline. That’s important – it’s also the reason people think infl is related to growth. Only headline.

  • I doubt we’ll get very close to core deflation in this cycle. See my recent article Last Time Was Different for why I don’t think we’ll see similar effects. But mkts are priced for long-term disinflation and deflation.
  • Oh and of course yesterday’s M2 chart. Probably discuss that more later today. Anyway, I’d say good luck but with markets closed you can’t do anything anyway! So just “hang on” and we’ll try and figure this out over the next few months.

  • I will be back in 5 minutes with thoughts on the figures and diving as deep as I can this month.
  • Core -0.1% m/m, down to 2.1% y/y. That’s a bigger fall than expected, but with these error bars I wouldn’t be shocked. Normally missing by 0.2% on core is a big deal. More interesting is that they got headline right to within 0.1%! It ‘only’ fell -0.4% m/m in March.
  • Here are the last 12 core CPI prints. This chart is gonna look kinda wacky for a while.

  • Broadly, core goods were -0.2% y/y, a decline from flat. More amazing is core services, dropping to 2.8% y/y from 3.1%.
  • Haha, that core services number is EVEN MORE AMAZING than you think. Because it didn’t happen from Owners Equivalent Rent (+0.26% m/m, 3.22% y/y) or Primary Rents (+0.30% m/m, 3.67% y/y). Both slower y/y but basically same m/m from Feb.
  • So if rents didn’t decelerate, where do we get the big drop in core services? Lodging Away From Home was -6.79% m/m, dropping to -6.38% y/y from +0.78% last month. I should drop the second decimal.
  • BTW, good time to remember that VOLUMES of transactions don’t enter into CPI monthly. This is just a survey of prices. So if no one bought any apparel, but we have a price, that’s what gets recorded. Lodging fell because prices actually were down hard, as you probably know.
  • CPI for Used Cars and Trucks was +0.82% m/m. Some people were worried about autos but I’m not sure they should be. Big supply shock in cars because of parts supply chain. If I were a dealer I wouldn’t be marking down my existing inventory.

  • Airfares -12.6% m/m. That’s worth about 0.1% on core all by itself. So we expected big declines in airfares and Lodging Away from Home (worth about 0.06%), and got them. Core ex- those two items still had some softness, but not horrendous.
  • Core ex-housing declined from 1.70% y/y to 1.45% y/y. Again, a lot of that were those two items I just mentioned. But 1.45% core ex-housing is still higher than it was last July.
  • Now, in medical care I’m not sure how to think about any of this. Medicinal Drugs were -0.04% m/m, after -0.43% last month, pushing y/y to 1.31% from 1.85%. But lots of drugs are really hard to get right now and of course we now know most of our APIs come from China.
  • That may be a case of some shortages, because in the short term no one wants to be seen jacking up the price of drugs. Prescription drugs decelerated y/y; non-prescription accelerated.
  • Physicians’ Services +0.34% m/m vs +0.21% prior month. Hospital Services +0.40% vs -0.12%. How in the heck do you measure this when most of those doctors and services are doing one thing? And a very crucial one indeed. What’s the price of a hip replacement right now?
  • OK, biggest m/m changes down, other than fuel. Public Transportation -65% (annualized), car/truck rental -58%, Lodging Away from Home -57%, Infants/toddlers apparel -41%, womens/girls apparel -30%, footwear -29%.
  • Which makes me realize I forgot to mention Apparel was -2% m/m. That’s another 5bps off the core inflation rate.
  • There were still some increases on the month. Biggest ones other than food were Tobacco and Smoking Products (12.5% annualized), nonalcoholic beverages (+12%), and Used Cars and Trucks (+10%).
  • FWIW, the early look to me is that MEDIAN CPI will still be around 0.22% or so. That’s what long-tail negatives do to core! So while y/y Core dropped sharply, y/y median will still be around 2.8%.
  • So, coarse but…core -0.1% m/m. Add back 0.06% lodging, 0.10% airfares, 0.07% apparel and 0.07% for public transportation (cuffing it) and you get back to +0.2%. Which means that outside of those categories there wasn’t much disinflation pulse. Median will say same thing.
  • That probably more means that prices haven’t really reacted yet that that there will be zero impact of COVID-19. But I don’t think we’ll see a big impact lower on prices. At least not lasting very long.
  • Haven’t done many charts yet. But here’s one I haven’t run in a while. Distribution of y/y price changes by low-level item categories in the CPI. Look at that really long tail to the left. Take off just the last bar on the left and you get 2.37% core roughly.

  • Here’s the weight of categories over 2% y/y change, over time. Just another way of saying that we haven’t seen any big effects yet. Unknown is just how much the trouble in collecting affects this.

  • Pretty good summary and gives me more confidence in the data – they’re at least calling people! But interestingly, not so much doctors/hospitals. So asterisk by Medical Care.
  • BLS has posted this, explaining how they’re collecting prices. https://bls.gov/bls/effects-of-covid-19-pandemic-on-bls-price-indexes.htm#CPI
  • So let’s do the four-pieces charts and then wrap up. For those new to my monthly CPI tweets, these four pieces add up to CPI, each is 20%-33%, but each behaves differently from a modeler’s perspective.
  • First piece: Food and Energy. This will go much lower. As I said up top, we will be in deflation of the headline number pretty soon. But, I think, only the headline number.

  • Core goods. This declined a tiny bit, mostly apparel. I think the short-term effect here is indeterminate but might actually be higher as some goods made overseas get harder to get (ibuprofen??)

  • Here’s where the rubber meets the road. Core Services less Rent of Shelter. Was in a good trend higher and about to be worrisome. Dropped a bit, but with an asterisk on medical care.

  • Rent of Shelter – this looks alarming! And rents declining is the ONLY way you can get core deflation. But…Rent of Shelter includes lodging away from home. That’s the dip, is in that 1% of CPI. The 31% that is primary and OER, not so much.

  • That last chart calls for one more on housing. Here is OER, the biggest single piece of CPI. It’s right on model. As yet, no sign of any big effect from COVID-19 either now, or in the forecast that’s driven by housing market data.

  • End with 1 final chart. We started w/ M2 chart showing the biggest y/y rise in history. The counterpoint is “what if velocity falls.” But vel is already @ record low. To drop, you need lower int rates (from 0?), or huge long-lasting cash-hoarding.Hard to see.

  • Thanks for tuning in. I’ll collate these in a single post in the next hour or so.

So what was most amazing about today’s data? I suppose it was that, outside of the things we knew would be disasters (airfares, hotels) the effects of the virus crisis were very small. And you know, that sort of makes sense. If I’m a producer of garden rakes (I honestly just pulled that out of the air), why would I change my prices? I’m not seeing traffic, but it isn’t because my prices are too high. From a seller’s perspective, it only makes sense to lower price if lower prices will induce more business. Lowering the price of rakes isn’t going to sell more rakes. It isn’t that people have no money to buy rakes – with the government fully replacing wages of laid off workers, and covering the wage costs for small businesses so they don’t need to lay anyone off, and sending everyone a fat check besides, there’s no shortage of people with money to spend. (I know we read a lot about the tragedy of the millions being laid off, but it’s not much of a tragedy yet since they’re being paid the same as before!)

[As an aside, businesses with high fixed overhead and low variable costs – hotels are a classic example; it costs very little for the second occupied guest room – might lower prices significantly since if they can cover their variable costs then anything above that goes to covering fixed overhead. That’s what airlines did initially too, but when they realized after that knee-jerk response that they couldn’t fill the planes even if they offered free flights, they started canceling enormous numbers of flights. I’ve actually seen some of the fares that I track rise in the last week or two as the number of flights out of NYC has dwindled to very few! But it’s harder to mothball a hotel than to mothball a plane.]

The NY Fed published a really insightful article today entitled “The Coronavirus Shock Looks More like a Natural Disaster than a Cyclical Downturn.” Although they focused on the path of unemployment claims, a similar analysis can take us to the inflation question. In a natural disaster, we don’t see deflation. If anything, we tend to see inflation as some goods get harder to acquire. The amount of money available doesn’t decline, assuming the government deploys an emergency response that includes covering non-insured losses, and the amount of goods available drops. In today’s circumstance, we have more money available – as the M2 chart shows – than we did before the crisis, and if anything we will have fewer things to buy when it’s all over as supply chains will remain disrupted for a long time and a lot of production will surely be re-onshored. But you don’t need the latter point to get disturbing inflation. All you need is for the money being created to get into circulation rather than reserves (which is what is happening, which is why M2 is soaring), and for precautionary money-hoarding to be a short-term phenomenon. I believe the money will be around long after the fear has died away, because for the Fed to drain a few trillion by selling massive quantities of bonds is much, much more difficult than to add a few trillion by buying bonds that the Treasury coincidentally needs to sell more of right now.

The quality of the CPI numbers will be sketchy for a while, but I am fairly impressed that this release wasn’t as messy as I was prepared for. The inflationary outcome may well be messy, though! With 14% money growth, and little reason to expect a lasting velocity decline, it’s hard to get an innocuous inflation outcome. But markets are still offering you inflation hedges at prices that imply you win even if inflation drops a fair amount from the current level. If you don’t have those hedges, you’re making a very big bet on deflation.

Happy Easter.

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (March 2020)

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments (updated site coming soon). Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

  • CPI day, coronavirus edition! Meaning that no matter what this month’s number is, next month’s number will be more “infected” and lots more interesting.
  • The consensus today is for core CPI to be a ‘soft’ +0.2%, with y/y core coming in at 2.3%.
  • Last month’s CPI figure was above expectations, but following a couple of weak months. Economists’ forecasts suggest they think the strength, not the weakness, was the outlier. I’m not so sure.
  • In last month’s CPI, core goods were weak, especially Used Cars and Pharmaceuticals. Both of those effects look to have recently reversed…altho question in both cases is whether it will be captured in the Feb number. Black Book figures have turned higher.
  • Important to note is the easy comparison of today’s CPI print to Feb 2019, which was only +0.127% core. So even a slightly strong 0.2% m/m could cause an uptick to 2.4% rounded on the y/y core.
  • Going forward, I’m really interested in housing, which has been resilient – if 10-year inflation markets are “right” at 1.0%, then Housing will have to collapse. I don’t see that.
  • And I think we are all more aware now that our supply chain of pharmaceuticals, specifically APIs, runs through China; efforts to bring back some drug manufacturing to the US will put upward pressure there.
  • That’s probably not this month’s story, but the Big Story to watch I think.
  • That’s all for now. 5 minutes to go…good luck with the number.
  • Well, core was +0.2% and the y/y was 2.4%, so that implies a strong core. But core figures being really slow to post to Bloomberg. That’s why the unnatural pause from me..
  • Weirdly getting entire breakdown except for core index level. Not sure if it’s a Bloomberg or a BLS issue but we’ll proceed. In any event looks like it was above 0.2% on core, and rounded down.
  • …and as I type that it comes in at +0.22%. That puts y/y core at 2.37%. That’s not QUITE the high for the cycle, but pretty close.
  • here is y/y core. I don’t see deflation yet, do you?

  • Last 12…the Oct and Dec figures looking more like the outliers.

  • Context for that. Here is the median CPI (which doesn’t come out until later) vs the 10y CPI swap rate. Clearly, market participants expect something big and negative.

  • Candidates for big and negative? It would have to be housing. But Owners’ Equivalent Rent this month was +0.246%. That’s softer than last month and the y/y fell to 3.28% from 3.35%…but not exactly weak.
  • Primary rents were unchanged y/y at 3.76%. Lodging Away from Home – to be sure, we ought to soon see that drop on the COVID-19 effect, was +2.03% m/m, but that only puts y/y at +0.78% from -0.21%. Lodging AFH hasn’t been a driver of inflation prints.
  • Now, possibly interesting, except that this is now a really volatile number, was the +0.43% jump in Apparel. China effect? Prob not yet. But y/y rose to -0.91% from -2.24% as recently as Oct. But the new survey method has made this volatile.
  • On Medical care – Pharma was -0.43% m/m, but that kept the y/y at 1.85% (was 1.80%). Last month Pharma was negative too. I’ll come back to drugs in a moment but Doctors’ Services rose to +0.83% y/y from +0.70% and Hospital Svcs to 4.28% from 3.84%.
  • Hospital Services y/y.

  • Recall 1 reason I’ve been expecting rise in Med Care is b/c insurance costs in the CPI have been soaring. But b/c of the way BLS measures insurance, as a residual, my hypothesis was that this was just proxying for stuff they hadn’t caught yet. But insurance STILL soaring!

  • So if I am right about the proxying effect, the recent rise in medical care pieces still leaves more to go.
  • I haven’t mentioned used cars yet. M/M used cars were +0.39%, moving y/y to -1.33% from -1.97%. The dip seems to be over. Recent surveys in last few weeks especially have seen surge in used car buying. Might be b/c auto manufacturing is having supply chain issues, or not.

  • Core CPI ex-housing rose to 1.70% y/y. That’s the highest level since Feb 2013. Again, I refer you to 10-year inflation breakevens, DOWN this morning to 0.99%. Just not seeing anything that even suggests a turn lower. Housing solid, and ex-housing at the highs.
  • …that doesn’t mean inflation can’t fall, and headline inflation in the near term is going to drop HARD because of energy, but to sell 10-year inflation at 1% you have to believe in more than an energy effect. Oil can’t fall 30% every month.
  • Again to sort of make the point that last month…while stronger than expected…was actually dragged LOWER by core goods: y/y core services stayed at 3.1%; y/y core goods rose to 0.0% vs -0.3% last month (but +0.1% month before).
  • One element of core goods is pharma. In the news recently b/c China supplies something like 90% of our APIs that go into drugs. This index has become lots more VOLATILE in recent yrs. Does that have anythng to do w/ the China part of supply chain becoming more important?

  • So biggest declining core categories this month: car/truck rental, misc personal goods, jewelry and watches. All down more than 10% annualized. Gainers: Lodging AFH, Women’s/Girls’ Apparel, Dairy (??), Personal Care Products. (Dairy not core, but unusual).
  • As if i didn’t already have enough reasons to give up ice cream. Here’s Dairy inflation, y/y. Come on, man.

  • Here is a little stealth inflation for you, although I suspect this will turn around. Here is y/y airfares, up at 2.35% y/y.

  • Why is that stealth inflation? Because airfares usually have a decent relationship to jet fuel. Except recently, they’ve been reluctant to fall. This is thru Feb since this is Feb CPI. Last point in red.

  • But here is jet fuel futures. This isn’t in CPI because consumers don’t buy jet fuel. Notice it was already declining in January and February before falling off a cliff this month. We OUGHT to be seeing this in airfares. Not yet, but soon.

  • last subcomponent pic today. This is college tuition & fees, y/y. This is going to start heading up unless the stock market starts to recover. When endowments take a beating, they share the pain.

  • Median CPI this month looks like it ought to be up around 0.26%ish. If that’s right, y/y median will be steady at 2.88% y/y.
  • Let’s see, why don’t we do the four pieces charts and then wrap up. Didn’t realize I’d been yammering for an hour.
  • Piece 1 is food & energy. Guess what: this is about to roll over, and hard. But it isn’t core, so it moves around a ton. We look through this volatility. Note the y axis scale!

  • Piece 2 is core goods. Back to roughly flat. Close to our model, but I’m still amazed this hasn’t seen more of an upswing yet with trade frictions. But I am pretty sure it will with COVID-19, because that’s a major supply shock and this is where it will tend to hit.

  • Still, of more concern is core services less rent-of-shelter. Significant weight here to medical care services, which as I showed earlier (see hospital services chart) is in a steady rise. Pharma shows up in core goods. The rest of medical shows up here.

  • Last but not least, rent of shelter. Solid as a rock. By the way, 10-year breakevens are down another 8bps today, to 0.95%. This makes zero sense. 1y CPI swaps? Different story. But 10y is nonsense.

  • Wrapping up: another stronger-than-expected number. I said last month that core CPI will be above 2.5% by summer, and we are still on track for that. COVID-19 might eventually pull prices lower if it becomes more demand shock than supply shock. We’re nowhere close to that now.
  • Of course, that doesn’t change the Fed’s decision. They’ll ease, aggressively. And the Federal government will spend like crazy. Folks, welcome to MMT. This is exactly what the MMT prescription is: deficit spend, and print money to cover it. We’ll see how it works out.
  • That’s all for today. Thanks for tuning in.

Nothing really further to add to this string of tweets. None of this stops the Fed from easing aggressively, but it wouldn’t have changed their decision much anyway because the Fed pretty much ignores inflation. But it should affect investment decisions. Really incredible to me is the way inflation bonds are underperforming so dramatically when they were already cheap and inflation is still rising. You have to be massively bearish, looking for a global collapse of monumental proportions, to want to sell 10-year inflation below 1% when housing is above 3% and ex-housing is at 7-year highs, and when the government is implementing MMT (effectively) and businesses are going to be under tremendous pressure to shorten supply chains and produce in higher-cost areas that are geographically safer/closer. It’s really hard to understand the TIPS market at the moment. (Some people say that it is always hard to understand the TIPS market!)

Categories: CPI, TIPS, Tweet Summary

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (February 2020)

February 13, 2020 1 comment

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments (updated site coming soon). Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

  • Welcome to CPI day! Before we get started, note that at about 9:15ET I will be on @TDANetwork with @OJRenick to discuss the inflation figures etc. Tune in!
  • In leading up to today, let’s first remember that last month we saw a very weak +0.11% on core CPI. The drag didn’t seem to come from any one huge effect, but from a number of smaller effects.
  • The question of whether there was something odd with the holiday selling calendar, or something else, starts to be answered today (although I always admonish not to put TOO much weight on any single economic data point).
  • Consensus expectations call for +0.2% on core, but a downtick in y/y to 2.2% from 2.3%. That’s not wildly pessimistic b/c we are rolling off +0.24% from last January.
  • Next month, we have much easier comparisons on the y/y for a few months, so if we DO drop to 2.2% y/y on core today that will probably be the low for a little while. Feb 2019 was +0.11%, March was +0.15%, April was +0.14%, and May was +0.11%.
  • So this month we are looking to see if we get corrections of any of last month’s weakness. Are they one-offs? We are also going to specifically watch Medical Care, which has started to rise ominously.
  • One eye also on core goods, though this should stay under pressure from Used Cars more recent surveys have shown some life there. Possible upside surprise because low bar. Don’t expect Chinese virus effect yet, but will look for signs of it.
  • That’s all for now…good luck with the number!
  • Small upside surprise this month…core +0.24%, and y/y went up to 2.3% (2.27% actually).
  • We have changes in seasonal adjustment factors and annual and benchmark revisions to consumption weights this month…so numbers are rolling out slowly.
  • Well, core goods plunged to -0.3% y/y. A good chunk of that was because Used Cars dropped -1.2% this month, down -1.97% y/y.
  • Core services actually upticked to 3.1% y/y. So the breakdown here is going to be interesting.
  • Small bounce in Lodging Away from Home, which was -1.37% m/m last month. This month +0.18%, so no big effect. But Owners Equivalent Rent jumped +0.34% m/m, to 3.35% y/y from 3.27%. Primary Rents +0.36%, 3.76% y/y vs 3.69%. So that’s your increase in core services.
  • Medical Care +0.18% m/m, 4.5% y/y, roughly unchanged. Pharma fell -0.29% m/m after +1.25% last month, and y/y ebbed to 1.8% from 2.5%. That goes the other way on core goods. Also soft was doctors’ services, -0.38% m/m. But Hospital Services +0.75% m/m.
  • Apparel had an interesting-looking +0.66% m/m jump. But the y/y still decelerated to -1.26% from -1.12%.
  • Here is the updated Used Cars vs Black Book chart. You can see that the decline y/y is right on model. But should reverse some soon.

  • here is medicinal drugs y/y. You can see the small deceleration isn’t really a trend change.

  • Hospital Services…

  • Primary Rents…now, this and OER are worth watching. It had been looking like shelter costs were flattening out and possibly even decelerating a bit (not plunging into deflation though, never fear). This month is a wrinkle.

  • Core ex-housing 1.53% versus 1.55% y/y…so no big change there. The upward pressure on core today is mostly housing.
  • Whoops, just remembered that I hadn’t shown the last-12 months’ chart on core CPI. Note that the next 4 months are pretty easy comps. We’re going to see core CPI accelerate from 2.3%.

  • So worst (core) categories on the month were Used Cars and Trucks and Medical Care Commodities, which we’ve already discussed. Interesting. Oddly West Urban OER looks like it was down m/m although my seasonal adjustment there is a bit rough.
  • Biggest gainers: Miscellaneous Personal Goods, +41% annualized! Also jewelry, footwear, car & truck rental, and infants/toddlers’ apparel.
  • Oddly, it looks like median cpi m/m will be BELOW core…my estimate is +0.22% m/m. That’s curious – it means the long tails are more on the upside for a change.
  • Now, we care about tails. If all the tails start to shift to the high side, that’s a sign that the basic process is changing.
  • One characteristic of disinflation and lowflation…how it happens…is that prices are mostly stable with occasional price cuts. If instead we go to mostly stable prices with occasional price hikes, that’s an inflationary process. WAY too early to say that’s what’s happening.
  • Appliances (0.2% of CPI, so no big effect) took another big drop. Now -2.08% y/y. Wonder if this is a correction from tariff stuff.
  • Gotta go get ready for air. Last thing I will leave you with is this: remember the Fed has said they are going to ignore inflation for a while, until it gets significantly high for a persistent period. We aren’t there yet. Nothing to worry about from the Fed.

Because I had to go to air (thanks @OJRenick and @TDAmeritrade for another fun time) I gave a little short shrift on this CPI report. So let me make up for that a little bit. First, here’s a chart of core goods. I was surprised at the -0.3% y/y change, but it actually looks like this isn’t too far off – maybe just a little early, based on core import prices (see chart). Still, there has been a lot of volatility in the supply chain, starting with tariffs and now with novel coronavirus, with a lot of focus on the growth effects but not so much on the price effects.

It does remain astonishing to me that we haven’t seen more of a price impact from the de-globalization trends. Maybe there is some kind of ‘anchored inflation expectations’ effect? To be sure, it’s a little early to have seen the effect from the virus because ships which left before the contagion got started are still showing up at ports of entry. But I have to think that even if tariffs didn’t encourage a shortening of supply chains, this will. It does take time to approve new suppliers. Still I thought we’d see this effect already.

Let’s look at the four pieces charts. As a reminder, this is just a shorthand quartering of the consumption basket into roughly equal parts. Food & Energy is 20.5%; Core Goods is 20.1%; Rent of Shelter is 32.8%; and Core services less rent of shelter is 26.6%. From least-stable to most:

We have discussed core goods. Core Services less RoS is one that I am keeping a careful eye on – this is where medical care services falls, and those indices have been turning higher. Seeing that move above 3% would be concerning. The bottom chart shows the very stable Rents component. And here the story is that we had expected that to start rolling over a little bit – not deflating, but even backing off to 3% would be a meaningful effect. That’s what our model was calling for (see chart). But our model has started to accelerate again, so there is a real chance we might have already seen the local lows for core CPI.

I am not making that big call…I’d expected to see the local highs in the first half of 2020, and that could still happen (although with easy comps with last year, it wouldn’t be much of a retreat until later in the year). I’m no longer sure that’s going to happen. One of the reasons is that housing is proving resilient. But another reason is that liquidity is really surging, so that even with money velocity dripping lower again it is going to be hard to see prices fall. M2 growth in the US is above 7% y/y, and M2 growth in the Eurozone is over 6%. Liquidity is at least partly fungible when you have global banks, so we can’t just ignore what other central banks are doing. Over the last decade, sometimes US M2 was rising and sometimes EZ M2 was rising, but the last time we saw US>7% and EZ>6% was September 2008-May 2009. Before that, it happened in 2001-2003. So central banks are providing liquidity as if they are in crisis mode. And we’re not even in crisis mode.

That is an out-of-expectation occurrence. In other words, I did not see it coming that central banks would start really stepping on the gas when global growth was slowing, but still distinctly positive. We have really defined “crisis” down, haven’t we? And this isn’t a response to the virus – this started long before people in China started getting sick.

So, while core CPI is currently off its highs, it will be over 2.5% by summertime. Core PCE will be running up on the Fed’s 2% target, too. If the Fed maintains its easy stance even then, we will know they are completely serious about letting ‘er rip. I can’t imagine bond yields can stay at 2% in that environment.

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (January 2020)

January 14, 2020 3 comments

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments or Enduring Intellectual Properties (updated sites coming soon). Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

  • The first CPI day of 2020! Although technically, this is the last print from the 20-teens.
  • The next decade ought to be very different from the last decade, from an inflation perspective. No more wondering if deflation is sneaking up on us, which is how 2010 began. I suspect we will spend more time worrying about how to put the inflation genie back in the bottle.
  • As the saying goes, letting the cat out of the bag is a heck of a lot easier than gettin’ him back in.
  • But let’s be more myopic for now: month on month. Consensus on core CPI is for +0.18% or so, which would keep y/y at 2.3% unchanged from last month.
  • To tick y/y core back to rounding to 2.4%, we only need 0.22% m/m on core CPI, so that’s more likely than the weakness we would need to see it tick down to 2.2%.
  • Last month in fact we saw 0.23%, which is right on the 6-month average core print. The only reason y/y is as low as it is, is because Feb-May last year were all 0.11-0.15% prints. Which is to say that the comps get easier starting in March (with Feb’s number).
  • Last month’s +0.23% came with softish housing, too. So there are some underlying upward pressures beyond housing. Medical Care has been getting the most attention so we will be attentive to any continued upward pressure there.
  • Also watch this month for an apparel bounce-back. Big drop last month, most likely due to the placement of Thanksgiving and the BLS’s new methodology which has induced lots of volatility to the series.
  • Downwardly, Used Cars remain a risk with private surveys showing softness there. And we’ll watch housing again. A sea change in housing would be a big deal. No real sign of that yet, and in fact housing has been running hotter than our forecasts by a tiny bit.
  • That’s all for now…good luck with the number. 5 minutes.
  • Weak CPI print, +0.11% on core…y/y just barely rounded up to 2.3% y/y. I said a downtick would be hard…but this was weak enough that it was very close.

  • Used Cars was quite weak, at +0.76% m/m, but that’s not super-surprising. The y/y at -0.68% (from -0.44%) is roughly in line.
  • Another usual suspect, Lodging Away from Home, plunged -1.75% m/m, putting the y/y to -0.28% from +3.26%. So a big, anti-seasonal move there. But LAfH is only 1% of CPI.
  • Overall housing was okay…OER +0.24% and Primary Rents +0.23% m/m, meaning that they upticked slightly y/y to 3.28% (vs 3.26%) and 3.69% (vs 3.66%) respectively. So it isn’t the big components there.
  • Yet Housing as a whole subgroup was only +0.10%. Was that all LAfH? Need to check.
  • Medical Care accelerated further, +0.57% m/m.

  • Medical care jump led by a large +1.25% m/m rise in Pharma (Medicinal Drugs).

  • The increases in the broad medical care components tends to support my prior suspicions that the big rise in CPI for health care insurance was a case of BLS not catching what was actually moving, so it appeared to show up in the insurance residual. That residual is still high…

  • Struggling finding anything (other than used cars and lodging away from home) that was really weak. Apparel was +0.40% m/m, so we got some of the bounceback. Recreation was a little weak, +0.15% m/m, and “Other” was -0.13% m/m…I need to dig deeper in housing though.
  • Overall core goods was steady at +0.10% y/y; overall core services was steady at +3.0% y/y. So no super clues there.
  • Here’s supporting chart for what I said about the weakness in Used Cars. Weak, but not surprisingly weak.

  • Well, in Housing…Shelter, which includes rents but also includes Lodging Away from Home, decelerated to 3.25% from 3.32% y/y. Fuels and Utilities is -0.23% y/y vs +0.74%. And Household Furnishings/Operations +0.98% vs 1.61%.
  • Looks like major appliances were heavy, down 1% m/m or so. But we’re talking a pretty small weight.
  • So biggest m/m decliners (and annualized changes) were Lodging AfH (-19.1%), Public Transport (-16.3%), Car and Truck Rental (-14.7%), and Personal Care Products (-12.9%). Cumulatively that’s only 2.8% of the CPI, but big changes.
  • Biggest m/m gainers aren’t in core: Motor Fuel (+39.6%) and Fuel Oil/Other Fuels (+27.4%). Medical Care Commodities (drugs) were +19.3%, and are in core, but as we have seen probably not a one-off. Then Meat, Poultry, Fish, and Eggs (can we just call this “protein?”) +16.7%.
  • So we’re talking about a lot of left-tail things in core especially. Median looks to be over 0.2% again, though a little hard to say because one of the regional OERs looks like the median category. But y/y Median CPI should stay roughly steady at 2.92% is my guess.
  • So core ex-shelter dropped a bit to 1.55% from 1.61% y/y. Still well off the lows. But if these left-tail one-offs are really one-offs, we would expect to see that rebound next month. Bottom line though is that 1.55% from non-housing isn’t very alarming yet.
  • To kinda state the obvious, nothing here will have the slightest impact on the Fed. They’ve basically said they don’t care about inflation at these levels. “Wake me when it hits 3% on core PCE, then hit the snooze button for a year.”
  • “In order to move rates up, I would want to see inflation that’s persistent and that’s significant. A significant move up in inflation that’s also persistent before raising rates to address inflation concerns: That’s my view.” – Powell, Dec 11 2019
  • Let’s look at the four pieces charts in order from most-volatile to least. First, Food and Energy.

  • Second, Core goods. This includes pharma, but also used cars, so right now the cars are beating drugs. (Don’t drink and drive, kids.)

  • Core Services less Rent of Shelter. Now, this month overall was weak but this is starting to look more concerning thanks to Medical Care. I think we might be seeing this over 3% before long, given the signals from health care.

  • And 4th piece: rent of shelter. So, flip side of the other core services is that rents might be softening..but at least aren’t showing an urgency to accelerate further. This was the reason I thought we’d see core peak in the 1st part of this year. I’m no longer confident.

  • Ever feel like inflation was giving you the finger? Here is the distribution of price changes. The big one in the middle is OER. The one at the far right is gasoline. You can see there are a lot of left tail events still.

  • Last one. Same data as the last chart, but this just sums all the categories over 3% y/y inflation. Obviously, when this goes over 50%, median is at least 3%. Because of rents, this is going to be close to 50%…but enough other categories are starting to scooch it there.

  • Scooch being a technical term.
  • OK, that’s all for today. The summary is that while the monthly number was soft, the underlying pressures are if anything getting a little firmer. Of course, the summary if you’re on the FOMC is, “CPI came out today? Really?”

As I said, nothing here will affect the Fed, at least for a while. I am sure some of them still pay attention to the CPI but they’ve made very clear that the only way inflation would affect monetary policy is if it went a lot higher, or a little bit lower. It may go a lot higher, but it won’t get there quickly. And core PCE, which is what the Fed supposedly focuses on (insider tip: they focus on whichever index is confirming their thesis), is more likely to accelerate from here since it overweights medical care – which is now trending higher – and underweights housing – which is looking soft – compared to private consumption. So, write off the Fed.

However, the “cyclical” ebbing of inflationary pressures that I had been expecting in Q1-Q2, mainly because I expected more softening in rents and I thought bond yields would be declining more in reaction to the slowdown in growth, aren’t apparent. It looks as if inflation might peak later than I had expected. Now, I never thought such a peak would mean inflation rolls over and goes to the lows of the last recession. Absent another collapse in housing, which does not appear to be in the offing, that isn’t going to happen. I thought inflation would stage a small retreat and then move to new highs when rates headed back up again. So far, though, I don’t even see much reason to think the peak is about to happen. Yes, rents are squishier than they were but it appears that medical care is moving fairly aggressively higher and interest rates don’t appear to be responding to the global slowdown in growth. So we might well be looking at a recession where inflation doesn’t slow very much.

In any event, the Fed’s response function make potential tail events a mostly one-way affair right now. They’ve warned you. Take appropriate precautions – which is relatively easy now as most inflation hedges (exception precious metals) are quite cheap!

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (December 2019)

December 11, 2019 Leave a comment

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments or Enduring Intellectual Properties (updated sites coming soon). Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

  • Okay, about 10 minutes to CPI showtime so let’s review last month.
  • We have had a couple of soft prints (<0.2% before rounding, one all the way to 0.1%, on core), but those followed 3 months of 0.3% monthly core prints. This month, consensus is for a soft 0.2% on core, something around 0.18%.
  • last month, we saw weak core goods, a lot of that being vehicles and NOT surprising but general softness outside of vehicles mildly surprising.
  • the bigger surprise was in housing, where Lodging Away from Home was very soft and both Primary and Owners’ Equivalent Rents were soft. That was the main story from last month.
  • But of course we are also watching Medical Care carefully. The prior rise in Medical Insurance inflation, because of the way the BLS measures, might (or might not) be a proxy for as-yet-unsurveyed strength in other medical subcomponents.
  • Those other medical care subcomponents HAVE been seeing some recent strength. So Core-Services-ex-Rents is something we are very interested in.
  • Two other points. The first is that November had a very late Thanksgiving, so depending on when retailers adjusted prices for the retail season (generally lowering them) and when the survey mostly happened, there could be some seasonal volatility.
  • If they did not lower their prices as early in the month, because Black Friday was later, that COULD mean we see strength that’s not seasonally expected. Don’t know but something to keep in mind. Built-in caveat for today.
  • Second point is: the Fed doesn’t care. Powell says they’re not going to tighten unless inflation goes significantly higher and stays there a long time. So, you’re on your own!
  • That’s all – grab a coffee and see you in 3 min.
  • 2% on core, but stronger than expected…really 0.23% before rounding. Y/Y core stays at 2.32%
  • Here are the last 12 core prints. Funny how one print can make the whole chart look more ominous.

  • OK, first housing. Lodging Away from Home was +1.1% m/m after -3.84% last month, so as-expected bounce. Primary Rents were +0.26% vs 0.14% last mo and OER was +0.24% vs +0.18%. So softness was not repeated in housing.
  • That said, the y/y figures in housing still declined, with Primary going to 3.66% vs 3.74% and OER 3.26% vs 3.31% prior. So those are big effects holding down y/y core. But core was unchanged y/y. So where were the gains?
  • I should say those are the effects holding down further acceleration in core. Drippy housing means th other parts need to pick up the slack.
  • Some of that is Medical Care. This month overall Medical Care CPI was +0.32% m/m, 4.24% y/y. That’s with soft Pharma CPI, -0.16% m/m and a scant 0.58% y/y.
  • You can see Pharma is still rising, this is y/y.

  • Doctors’ Services and Hospital Services also softer this month than last, but not huge.
  • Core Goods overall slumped to +0.1% y/y from 0.8% just a few months ago. This month, the weakness in pharma helped but the y/y for Used Cars also fell to -0.44% from +1.43% previously. Expected some weakness, but that might be a bit overdone.
  • Here is core commodities vs lagged import prices. Not super surprising that it is slowing.

  • Core inflation ex-shelter basically unchanged, at 1.61% vs 1.60%.
  • Unfortunately having some computer “issues” that is preventing my usual deeper dive in some of these categories.
  • Oh, Apparel -2.29% y/y vs -0.34%. Again, the BLS’s new survey methodology is introducing IMO a lot of extra volatility in this series.
  • Well, found the computer issue but it’s really that the BLS posted the subcomponents a little later than usual today. Won’t be fixed in the next few minutes and I have to go meet clients in Minneapolis. So I’ll wrap it up, a little short this month – sorry.
  • I think the bottom line is that there isn’t anything super surprising here. The softness we had seen in housing took at least a temporary hiatus. Overall core was stronger than expected, but hard to be sure that’s meaningful.
  • As I said up top, there’s no real reason to think that the Fed cares…so from a markets perspective, TODAY and this month, these numbers don’t mean much. Except for you, because the Fed isn’t going to try and restrain inflation so you better make sure you’re prepared.

Late post of today’s summary, since I had customer meetings during the day. Up above, I sort of flippantly commented about how the chart of monthly changes looks totally different when you add the latest point. I’m always fascinated about examples like this. Clearly, we didn’t add 12 monthly points, but only one today. So there is no more information in that chart than we had new today – what happens is that we change the context a little bit. Prior to today’s figure, the question was “are the three high numbers the aberration, or are the last two points an aberration from a higher trend?” The latest point makes it seem more likely that the two low ones are the aberration, but I’d be cautious about reading too much into that. First, there’s a ton of noise in any economic series. Second, I mentioned in my walk-up to the number in the bullet points above that there’s some chance the late Thanksgiving could result in a higher-than-expected CPI if retailers lowered their prices for the Christmas season later than normal. And third, there wasn’t anything super-alarming about this data.

By the same token, “nothing super-alarming” could also be read as “no big outliers, just a generally faster pace of inflation.” So if you’re bullish on inflation, you might read the composition that way. Moreover, it should be pointed out that while the consensus forecast was for +0.2% on core CPI, and we got +0.2%, there was actually a pretty decent miss: the consensus was more like +0.18% before rounding up, and core CPI was +0.23% before rounding down. Economists were further off than they appear to be if you just look at the rounded figures.

My view continues to be that inflation ought to peak early next year, but that the cyclical low won’t be that low. However, I am becoming a bit less confident that the peak is that near, especially given how Medical Care is behaving. The key point though is the last one I raised today. The Fed has changed the rules of the game…or I guess a better analogy is that it has changed which team it is playing for in a very vocal way. It is one thing for the Fed to say “we want inflation higher and are going to push it higher,” which implies a level of control (to be sure, it is control they don’t actually have), but something else entirely to say “we really don’t care if it goes up,” which implies abdication of responsibility for the results. Investors should beware of this. I don’t think it is the small thing it sounds like.

Categories: CPI, Tweet Summary

Summary of My Post-CPI Tweets (November 2019)

November 13, 2019 Leave a comment

Below is a summary of my post-CPI tweets. You can (and should!) follow me @inflation_guy. Or, sign up for email updates to my occasional articles here. Investors with interests in this area be sure to stop by Enduring Investments or Enduring Intellectual Properties (updated sites coming soon). Plus…buy my book about money and inflation. The title of the book is What’s Wrong with Money? The Biggest Bubble of All; order from Amazon here.

  • Another CPI day dawns bright and cold. But will inflation get heated up again, with a fourth 0.3% print on core, out of five? Or stay cold like last month’s +0.13% on core?
  • Last month, core goods was pressured a little bit, although still +0.7% y/y, by softness in Used Car prices and a big drop in pharma prices.
  • Apparel also fell as the new methodology is adding more volatility to that series than we had previously seen.
  • I suspect we will see more softness from Used Cars (maybe not as much as last month), as sales surveys have been consistently soggy recently.
  • I also continue to wait for the other shoe to drop with Medical Care. The Health Insurance part, which is a residual, has been running really hot. But that probably just signals that survey prices of the other parts need to catch up with reality. At least that’s my speculation.
  • Although core CPI was soft last month, Median was +0.25% and a new cycle high of 2.97% y/y. So the underlying pressures are steady and that probably means we aren’t about to see a major turn lower yet.
  • Really, the major change since last month has been the Fed’s tone – Powell saying that the Fed won’t even consider addressing higher inflation until they see “a really significant move up in inflation that’s persistent.”
  • That changes the calculation for investors and we have seen a meaningful move higher in breakevens recently as a result.
  • Consensus for today’s number is +0.3% headline, +0.2% on core, with the y/y core staying at 2.4%. And they’re really calling for an 0.2% or above, not a ‘soft’, rounded-up, core figure.
  • We are rolling off 0.196% from last October, so to have the y/y rise we need another pan-0.2% print. And to keep y/y at 2.4% on core it can’t be much softer than that.
  • That’s all for now. Except for this: after the figure I will be on @TDANetwork with @OJRenick. About 9:15ET is when we are scheduled to go to air. Tune in! And good luck today.
  • Soft one, +0.16% on core that rounds up to +0.2%. The y/y core dripped from 2.36% to 2.32%, which caused the rounded figure to go 2.4% to 2.3%.
  • So, what happened in June-July-August? Three months is a lot for an outlier.

  • OK, wow, -3.84% m/m drop in Lodging Away from Home. Looks like a seasonal distortion as the prior month was +2.09%. LAfH is only 1% of consumption, but that means it’s ~4bps of the m/m figure.
  • Used Cars and Trucks rebounded to 1.32% m/m, but the y/y dropped to 1.44% from 2.61%. It may have a little further to drop but that’s not surprising.
  • Apparel -1.8% m/m, so again more volatility from the new methodology. Core goods y/y dropped from +0.7% to +0.3%, but some part of that was Apparel going from -0.3% y/y to -2.3% y/y.
  • In the big pieces, Primary rents were +0.14%, a little soft (y/y to 3.74% from 3.83%) and Owner’s Equivalent +0.19%, also soft, to 3.32% from 3.40% y/y. Along with Lodging Away from Home it meant the Housing subindex, 42% of CPI, decelerated to 2.89% from 3.03%.
  • That’s potentially big on a couple of fronts, if it indicates actual slowing in rent inflation. As a big piece of CPI, a modest slowing there will help turn Median too.
  • Belated but here’s the chart on used cars and trucks. You can see the y/y is back in line, but some more softness likely.

  • So, core inflation ex-housing actually rose to 1.60% from 1.55%. Pretty minor move but it hasn’t been higher since Feb 2016, with the exception of two months ago when it hit 1.70%.

  • So the spread of shelter inflation over core, non-shelter inflation, has been extreme and one question has been whether housing inflation would slow or other inflation would rise. Answer this month is: both.

  • Not to belabor Lodging Away from Home but here is the y/y. The monthly volatility is not helpful, but at least it’s only 0.9% of CPI.

  • Weirdly, I haven’t mentioned Medical Care. M/M, Medicinal Drugs rose 1.05% after declining -0.79% last month. Y/y rose to +1% from -0.3%. Doctors’ Services rose to 1.16% y/y from +0.93%. But Hospital Services jumped to 3.46% from 2.08% y/y.
  • Hospital Services is 2.2% of consumption, and that +1.38% m/m jump is the reason that Core Services rose to 3% y/y from 2.9% DESPITE the deceleration in housing.
  • y/y hospital services. So is that part of what wasn’t being captured and thus showing up in the health insurance residual? Maybe, but Health Insurance still went to +20.1% y/y from 18.8%. Even knowing that’s a residual doesn’t keep it from being scary.

  • It’s measuring a REAL COST INCREASE, it’s just not really in the price of insurance policies that Americans are paying. Yes, they’re rising, but not at 20% y/y.
  • Insurance chart

  • Early guess on Median is that it will be a softish +0.19%, which will keep y/y basically unch.
  • Biggest annualized declines this month were Lodging Away from Home, Women/Girls’ Apparel, Infants’/Toddlers’ Apparel, and Men’s/Boys Apparel. Biggest increases: Car/Truck Rental, Motor Fuel, Misc Personal Goods, Energy Services, Used Cars/Trucks, Med Care Commodities.
  • Those are biggest annualized MONTHLY declines, Sorry.
  • About to get ready to air on @TDANetwork, so four-pieces charts might have to wait until later.
  • Summary today is that as usual there are lots of moving pieces but the interesting bit is the big housing pieces. They’re slow but there’s some anecdotal signs of softness developing and if that’s real, it could cap core inflation for now. Not sure of that yet.
  • I still think inflation is likely to peak for this cycle in early 2020, but again I admonish that the downside won’t be nearly as low as we have seen downsides and the next upside will be worse than this one. Higher highs and higher lows from here.

I still owe you the four-pieces charts, so here they are. First, Food & Energy.

Next, Core Goods. It suffered a big setback today but it still looks generally uptrending. I don’t think this is about to go to 4, but something between 0.5% and 1.0% for a while is not hard to imagine especially if pharma prices stabilize.

Core services, ex rent-of-shelter. Now, this starts to look a little more interesting? Medical Care showing some perkiness and as the second-most-stable piece here, core services less rent of shelter is worth monitoring for the longer-term macro inflation picture.

Finally, Rent of Shelter. Still in the same general vicinity, but there are starting to be some anecdotal reports of softness in home prices in certain areas so it’s worth monitoring. It’s not about to plunge as in 2007-09, but it just needs to back off a little to change how concerned we are about inflation.

That said, inflation seems to be broadening a bit and also becoming more volatile. The volatility is partly because the BLS is changing the way they do certain things but it’s also a consequence of fractious trade relationships where firms are changing their sourcing, prices are responding to tariffs and tariff threats, etc. To the average consumer who encodes price increases as inflation and price decreases as good shopping, volatility in prices feels very much like inflation so if this continues then inflation expectations could rise just on the volatility (unless it’s all measurement volatility, of course).

I do think that the investment implication of today’s inflation numbers is muted compared to the implication of what the Fed has said about the inflation numbers. To wit, the Fed won’t even consider hiking to restrain inflation unless they see “a really significant move up in inflation that’s persistent.” So far we haven’t seen that, and in fact recently the upper tails have been coming down just as the fast as the lower tails have been going up. The chart below shows what proportion of the CPI is inflating faster than 4% y/y.

But from an investor’s standpoint and more importantly from an advisor’s standpoint, the Fed stance changes how you approach a portfolio if you are a professional-risk-minimizer (as most advisors are). In the old days, an uptick in inflation that caught an advisor flat-footed might be forgiven because we assumed the Fed was working hard in our direction – to keep inflation low. But now, even if you don’t think inflation is going to rise, the professional risk on the downside is bigger because clients will say to the advisor “why didn’t we have any inflation hedges? The Fed told you they wanted expectations to go higher!” Maybe this is too subtle, but breakevens are up 20-25bps over the last few weeks and I think no small part of that is because investors and advisors are now on their own with respect to inflation. In my experience, people who think they might be shot at can usually be trusted to dig their own foxholes.

%d bloggers like this: